4 ms·
This article seems to equate "exhaustively understand" with "can be simulated down to an atomic level". I think that's not a good way to go about it. A cube of
by adrianN 10y ago
This article seems to equate "exhaustively understand" with "can be simulated down to an atomic level". I think that's not a good way to go about it. A cube of silicon with 1cm side length has about 10^20 atoms. Storing one bit for each atom would use exabytes of memory. Luckily, we don't have to simulate the cube at that level of precision to get a pretty good idea about how it behaves.
The "we could just simulate the whole brain down to the quarks" argument is an argument for the existence of AI. Nobody seriously suggests that it's the practical path forward to achieving it.
- jszymborski 10y agoI agree with your general premise, that abstraction is essential and sufficient for us to understand a lot of the functions and mechanisms of the cell. I do, however, think that the author is right in calling the cell ferociously complex, and that a lot of the abstractions we use hide and gloss over a chaotic system whose particulars can explain a lot of unexplained or misunderstood processes. That's fine to help us get an initial understanding, but you always want to drill down to a lower level abstraction until you (don't) reach the bottom of the stack of turtles. Biology undergoes a major paradigm shift couple of decades, and minor paradigm shifts on an even more regular basis, and I attribute that largely to the increasing resolution with which we're able to observe things. Ten years ago, microscopes were shittier, we were using microarrays instead of RNA/DNA-seq, we weren't using biotinylated-fusion proteins... but that stuff was necessary for us to really prove in a persuasive way ground-breaking shifts like that the DNA->Protein->Function paradigm isn't sufficient to describe a lot of what goes on in a cell. PREEMPTIVE EDIT: I know that DNA->Protein->Function paradigm was questioned way earlier than 2007, but it's taken a lot of persuasive evidence since then using modern techniques to get things like lncRNAs implicated in cancer
- RobertoG 10y ago"a lot of the abstractions we use hide and gloss over a chaotic system whose particulars can explain a lot of unexplained or misunderstood processes." Is not that always the case with abstractions? In fact, is not their point? The article says: "How far is human science from understanding a human brain? [..] Assuming that each neuron contains 175 trillion atoms, the total brain contains roughly 2 * 10^25 atoms." Well, by the same logic, we could argue that we don't understand cars.
- amatic 10y ago>Well, by the same logic, we could argue that we don't understand cars Or, by similar logic, that we don't understand how the planets of the solar system interact. It seems that in the history of science, initial views of complex things as chaotic got gradually replaced with better abstractions. As in, the word 'planet' means 'wanderer', then there were epicycles, perfect circles, elipses... I'm not a biologist, but maybe the current abstractions and models of cells are waiting for their Newtons and Mendeleevs to figure out the right models.
- adrianN 10y agoThe epicycle theory was actually pretty good and explained planet motion to the precision that measurements of that time provided.
- adrianN 10y agoI agree that better methods of observation tend to yield radical new insights and I'm pretty excited about all the cool things we can do, for example by adding fluorescent markers to biomolecules. But I don't believe that the simplest model that can perfectly explain a behavior of a cell is even in the same ballpark as an atom-scale simulation.
- zeteo 10y ago> The "we could just simulate the whole brain down to the quarks" argument is an argument for the existence of AI. Nobody seriously suggests that it's the practical path forward to achieving it. Yes, but you have to consider that funding will normally go to research programs that can show steady progress - even if it'll be 10 million times more work (of the same kind) to have a potentially useful result. Here's the discoverer of the electron, J. J. Thomson, explaining it far better than I can: “If you pay a man a salary for doing research, he and you will want to have something to point to at the end of the year to show that the money has not been wasted. In promising work of the highest class, however, results do not come in this regular fashion, in fact years may pass without any tangible results being obtained, and the position of the paid worker would be very embarrassing and he would naturally take to work on a lower, or at any rate, different plane where he could be sure of getting year by year tangible results which would justify his salary. The position is this: you want this kind of research, but if you pay a man to do it, it will drive him to research of a different kind. The only thing to do is to pay him for doing something else and give him enough leisure to do research for the love of it.”
- adrianN 10y agoLuckily at the current stage any work that improves our atom-scale brain simulations is wildly beneficial to all kinds of fields, so the funding is not wasted.
- sn9 10y agoBut the information contained in the two examples (silicon cube vs cell) are several orders of magnitude apart in complexity. I don't think that's really a great counter to the thesis of the OP. Though I agree that simulating down to an atomic level is probably not necessary, understanding will come from analysis closer to that level of granularity of analysis than it would from [given so many units of volume of a cell, we can conclude that X and thus achieve understanding].