3 ms·
Thanks for this. I think I remember at the time that there were still questions about the study. And generally when a study matches my sentiment of "Of course t
by danso 10y ago
Thanks for this. I think I remember at the time that there were still questions about the study. And generally when a study matches my sentiment of "Of course that's the case" I'm inclined to treat it with skepticism.
Priceonomics had more detail in a 2014 post, which mentions that the Israeli Courts Research Decision did indeed reject the findings on the basis that the study didn't fully consider the mundane details of how cases were scheduled: https://priceonomics.com/justice-isnt-blind-its-cranky-by-5pm/ https://priceonomics.com/justice-isnt-blind-its-cranky-by-5p...
The study's authors, according to Priceonomics, had argued against this explanation but they also conceded that they were unable to account for other factors, such as lawyers with multiple clients who decide which order to present them. And how prisoners without lawyers would typically come up right before the break.
- schoen 10y agoIt would still be very interesting to study judges' consistency and inter-rater reliability. There was someone's blog post that suggested doing empirical studies of trials by jury to see how often juries tended to agree with each other (with the suggestion that if there's a very high random component, it's harder to think of the juries' decisions as all reflecting a notion of justice). I've now also forgotten who proposed that.