5 ms·

Given the level of detail in the Australian article (or what we can see quoted from it; the original seems to be not easily available at the moment), and FB's p

Given the level of detail in the Australian article (or what we can see quoted from it; the original seems to be not easily available at the moment), and FB's past behavior[2], I'm not sure I believe their denial at this stage, quite frankly. We'll know for sure when the original presentation that the article refers to inevitably leeks out in full. [1] According to the Australian, the data available to advertisers includes a young user’s relationship status, location, number of friends on the platform and how often they access the site on mobile or desktop. The newspaper reported that Facebook also has information on users who are discussing “looking good and body confidence” and “working out & losing weight”. [2] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jun/29/facebook-users-emotions-news-feeds https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/jun/29/facebook-...

danderino 10y ago
>The newspaper reported that Facebook also has information on users who are discussing “looking good and body confidence” and “working out & losing weight” What's wrong with that exactly? Is that any different than an option to advertise to people who are talking about buying cars?
- kafkaesq 9y ago
  Because it's creepy. More specifically: it explicitly attempts to address a particular mental and psychological states (in particular, states associated with anxiety and the need for approval from others) rather than an economic activity (like "needs a car"). Yes, car ads (and all kind of ads) have implicitly been designed to work off feelings of anxiety (and the need to fit i), since the beginning of time. But it's the all-out brazenness off this effort (combined with the fact that, again, it was explicitly designed to target teenagers) that pushes it over the edge, in my view -- and well into the terrain of Creepy.

danderino 10y ago

>The newspaper reported that Facebook also has information on users who are discussing “looking good and body confidence” and “working out & losing weight” What's wrong with that exactly? Is that any different than an option to advertise to people who are talking about buying cars?

kafkaesq 9y ago
Because it's creepy. More specifically: it explicitly attempts to address a particular mental and psychological states (in particular, states associated with anxiety and the need for approval from others) rather than an economic activity (like "needs a car"). Yes, car ads (and all kind of ads) have implicitly been designed to work off feelings of anxiety (and the need to fit i), since the beginning of time. But it's the all-out brazenness off this effort (combined with the fact that, again, it was explicitly designed to target teenagers) that pushes it over the edge, in my view -- and well into the terrain of Creepy.