3 ms·
Here's the problem with saying include "age, sex, race, socio-economic..." as being /objective/ is that it literally repeats existing stereotypes and biases.
by olliej 10y ago
Here's the problem with saying include "age, sex, race, socio-economic..." as being /objective/ is that it literally repeats existing stereotypes and biases.
There's plenty of evidence that there is a huge amount of bias due to race, being poor means you can't afford good lawyers, etc. So now what happens is the information hat feeds into the algorithm is going to be something like "<X> currently receives longer sentences" leads it to just repeat the existing behaviour, but now it claims to be a machine and so unbiased, so judges defer to it.
I feel that as a defendant i should be able to ask them to re-run the algorithm with a changed race and a changed zip code so we can get a comparison and measure of effective algorithmic bias.
- iplaw 10y agoMy suggestion was to 1) not use any data or algorithms, or 2) use an objective algorithm to figure out if poor white males with criminal records but with a new child are likely to be repeat violent offenders. I did not suggest to use a single variable, nor did I suggest that it be used to determine guilt, explicitly dictate sentencing, etc. If there is going to be any algorithmic "fact" finding, it should involve plugging in all available data for a defendant and trending it against all available data. Not cherry picking.