6 ms·
This is crazy. "In such markets, the value of housing is no longer based on its social use. Properties are equally valuable regardless of whether they are vaca
by valuearb 10y ago
This is crazy.
"In such markets, the value of housing is no longer based on its social use. Properties are equally valuable regardless of whether they are vacant or occupied, so there is no pressure to ensure properties are lived in. They are built with the intention of lying empty and accumulating value, while at the same time, homelessness remains a persistent problem."
A home lying empty has a negative return (due to maintenance and operating costs, still have to water lawns, repair weather damage, etc). A home being rented has a higher return. There is simply no reason from an investors perspective to leave a home empty unless you can't find a renter who will cover their costs, or you are trying to sell it.
It's people like the author of this study that created the housing bubble in the US. They pushed to lower lending requirements, and pushed to have the US Government assume more risk so more easy money was available for housing purchases. With Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the US hasn't had a free market in housing for 70 years.
And worse, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are integrally connected to both political parties, offering huge payouts to retiring politicians or their friends in return for their support. Google the ex-DNC chairman who made $100M+ as chairman of Fannie Mae's board.
- objclxt 10y ago> There is simply no reason from an investors perspective to leave a home empty unless you can't find a renter who will cover their costs Right now the four bed house next door to me in San Francisco is empty, and has been empty for the past three years - it's worth $4 million, and is owned by a family based in mainland China. On one occasion a representative of theirs stopped me in the street and asked if my home was for sale (fortunately for me my landlord decided it wasn't). And when I lived in London I saw equally empty properties - new build flats worth millions of pounds completely deserted. > A home lying empty has a negative return (due to maintenance and operating costs, still have to water lawns, repair weather damage, etc). Not if the value of the home increases greater than the negative pressures...which it very much has been in many cities. > A home being rented has a higher return. There is simply no reason from an investors perspective to leave a home empty unless you can't find a renter who will cover their costs Tenants have their own problems. They have rights, homes are harder to liquidate with a tenant in, and you may decide it's just not worth the hassle. If you're expecting the property value to increase 50% over the next few years the income a tenant would be providing you is a relative pittance.
- valuearb 10y agoAgain, you are pointing out that the real problem is with restrictive rental regulations. If you can't easily require a renter to leave at the end of their lease, you would never rent your home, even if you didn't plan to live in it for a few years. But again, you get the appreciation whether you rent or not. It's in an investors best interest to rent, as long as they don't have to give up control of the property doing so.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pyoung 10y agoSingle family homes in SF are exempt from rent control.
- tobtoh 10y agoIn Australia, you can terminate a lease without issues if you intend to sell the property or move in yourself. However, in Melbourne, it's estimated (from water usage analysis) that 20% (1) of investor owned properties are vacant (4.8 per cent of greater Melbourne's total housing stock and 18.9 per cent of all investor-owned housing stock). So I don't believe the 'restrictive rental regulations' are primarily to blame. Anecdotally, the inner-city 2 bedroom house (worth around A$1.5M) behind where I live has been unoccupied ever since I moved in ten years ago! I'm as baffled as you that people do this! (1) http://www.afr.com/real-estate/almost-20pc-of-melbournes-investorowned-homes-empty-20151203-glee9q http://www.afr.com/real-estate/almost-20pc-of-melbournes-inv...
- DesiLurker 10y agoNo, the point he is highlighting is that often real estate is the best way to park large sums of money for foreign investors (however they may have gotten, in India its called black money) they often dont really care for making a little on the top with rent. infact view it as hindrance should they need to unload it (think high gini coefficient countries). This is really hurtful for working people living in that market as for them it translates into unbearable high prices by distorting rental markets. the only reason this has recently slowed down is because fincen has started cracking down on such purchases. btw this also happened after 2008 crash when banks forclosed a lot of properties but wernt selling any so they ended up holding onto them for long periods. some counties had to pass measures on similar lines. long term markets are efficient, short term not much so.
- k-mcgrady 10y ago>> A home lying empty has a negative return (due to maintenance and operating costs, still have to water lawns, repair weather damage, etc). A home being rented has a higher return. There is simply no reason from an investors perspective to leave a home empty unless you can't find a renter who will cover their costs, or you are trying to sell it. Maybe it depends on WHERE the property is. Your perspective doesn't ring true with e.g. a flat in a major city (London for example). No lawns to take care of our weather damage to deal with. Really very little to zero maintenance. Rent it and you have lots of laws to comply with, agencies to deal with, appliances and furniture to install, and when things break you pay for them. Also, renters are going to create a lot of wear and tear and their deposit is unlikely to cover it (and with laws around deposits every penny needs to be accounted for which isn't easy with general wear and tear).
- valuearb 10y agoThen your argument is with rental regulations. But it's absurd to think that even with the most restrictive regulations that apartments that would rent for thousands of dollars per month can't be rented profitably.
- VLM 10y agoWhy is it absurd, if you put numbers to it? I make 95%th percentile income. I live in a 95th percentile house deep in the burbs. I'm in a lifestyle where a 95th percentile urban apartment is completely uninteresting to me, my numerous neighbors agree. To maximize return all condo construction downtown has been ultra luxury out of my income range, but for the sake of argument, we'll claim its affordable by a mere 95th percenter, but if I don't want to live there, it doesn't matter if there is available rental property nor does it matter if there's 5, 10, or 15 condo towers at the same price currently under construction. There's enough of a local pyramid of incomes such that most of my fellow 95%ers are already living in the burbs and no amount of urban construction will get us downtown. So there are a lot of empty condos downtown, kind of like 2007 all over again but for a different reason. Building something to a specific rental cost, does not obligate people to live in it, or earn enough money to pay for it. Its like the classic micro vs macro economic effect of education argument. On a micro scale all individuals benefit from more education it always raises an individuals quality of life. On a macro scale requiring education in excess of the job reqs merely ties up labor and capital in unproductive activity, it lowers everyone's quality of life. What government policy should be, perhaps to bulldoze the schools, should naturally be the opposite of parental individual advice, to attend college. Likewise on an individual case basis constructing the most expensive possible condo is always financially most individually rewarding, yet the same act on a city wide basis the result is horrible and awful. I could build a nice condo for a SV google employee to live in, at SV google salary. The 2000 mile commute means its useless. The point isn't the commute itself, the point is if you don't build what people want, it doesn't matter if an abstract mathematical number implies the rent should be perfect, they're just not going to rent. There is a side issue that census figures seem to imply there's 5-10 million people in or above my household income percentile so lets call it 3 million families for the sake of argument. Lets say there's 6 million residences at or above my percentile of income. Lets say all urban condo construction to the level of 1 million residences per year is at a floor of my income (actually higher than my income, plenty of places I can't afford). If there's only 3 million families at my level of wealth across the entire country, and 6 million residences in the form of recently constructed condos and mcmansions and real homes too, there's simply gonna be a lot of empty real estate and more every year. As long as the banks are willing to fund it, more will be constructed. The fed will manipulate things to keep it affordable to keep employment high. I'm not necessarily offended. I my dads generation Detroit made cars engineered to rust and fall apart in two years, which was incredibly environmentally wasteful, while their houses were constructed to last centuries. My generation makes residences no one can afford to live in that take only a decade to fall apart whereas our cars are engineered to operate longer than the house are designed to stand. I'm sure there are abandoned mcmansions that are unlivable today that are younger than my wifes car which stubbornly refuses to break.
- keithpeter 10y ago"There is simply no reason from an investors perspective to leave a home empty unless you can't find a renter who will cover their costs, or you are trying to sell it." And yet there are thousands of empty flats within a three mile radius of me now in a large European city. They are monopoly counters my friend.