4 ms·
Nit: The first stage does not boost the second stage to orbital velocity. It boosts it to ~2,000 m/s, which is one-quarter of an orbital velocity, and one-sixte
by vkou 10y ago
Nit: The first stage does not boost the second stage to orbital velocity. It boosts it to ~2,000 m/s, which is one-quarter of an orbital velocity, and one-sixteenth of the energy required for orbit.
I don't believe it's likely that we'll see recovery of an orbital velocity stage anytime soon.
- rohit89 10y agoMusk said that they might attempt second stage recovery late next year for the Falcon Heavy.
- trose 10y agoSlightly different but yeah. The falcon has a single pre-orbit stage. The heavy has two pre-orbit stages. So it'll end up being three falcon engines stitched together with decouplers. Part of the way to orbit, the outside two decouple and return the to launch pad. Some time after that, the center engine decouples and lands on a barge. None of those will be going at orbit velocity though.
- Robotbeat 10y agoBut Musk has now said they are going to try upper stage reuse for Falcon Heavy. Not just the boosters: http://www.space.com/36412-spacex-completely-reusable-rocket-elon-musk.html http://www.space.com/36412-spacex-completely-reusable-rocket...
- Robotbeat 10y agoIndeed. Minor nit: the Falcon Heavy demo flight (with upper stage recovery attempt) is set for late THIS year, it's just that Musk puts the odds of successful upper stage recovery fairly low: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/847882289581359104 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/847882289581359104 Musk is "fairly confident" to have upper stage reuse operational by sometime next year: http://www.space.com/36412-spacex-completely-reusable-rocket-elon-musk.html http://www.space.com/36412-spacex-completely-reusable-rocket... Musk is notorious for doubling down on bets when the first bet seems like it most likely will succeed. I would bet you we'll see upper stage recovery within 1 or 2 years, with reuse of that stage within 2 to 4 years. (Particularly if SpaceX doesn't suffer another major failure within the next 2 years... Failures are always a significant possibility in this business given enough launches.) That counts as pretty darned soon.
- jessriedel 10y ago> I don't believe it's likely that we'll see recovery of an orbital velocity stage anytime soon. I understand it's a very different beast, but why do you think this is so much harder technologically? We bring things back from orbital velocity routinely, indeed much more frequently than anyone landed a rocket vertically prior to SpaceX.
- Robotbeat 10y agoAgreed. And with Dragon, SpaceX actually has a ton of experience with orbital reentry.
- nickjarboe 10y agoNit: The energy of an object going 2,000 m/s is 1/16th of that going 8,000 m/s, but since this is a rocket launching from Earth the energy for the rocket to get to 2,000 m/s is much greater than the energy to go from 2,000 m/s to 8,000 m/s [1]. Just look at how much larger the first stage (mass almost all propellant) is compared to the second stage (large fraction of the mass is the payload). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation
- vkou 10y agoThat has nothing to do with the rocket launching from Earth (A rocket in space follows the same rules), and everything to do with the fact that rockets expend most of their energy to push their own fuel. That fact is incredibly relevant for getting to orbit - however, it is not at all relevant for surviving re-entry, where all that matters is your kinetic energy.
- nickjarboe 10y agoThe Earth part was just shorthand for the fact that the atmosphere and gravity of Earth add about 1.3–1.8 km/s of delta v to achieving the pure kinetic delta v of 7.8 km/s needed to achieve LEO [1]. The first stage adds almost all of this "extra" delta v. I was mostly just correcting your "one-sixteenth of the energy required for orbit" statement. I agree that reentering at 7.8 km/s is much more difficult than 2.0 km/s, but the second stage is smaller and more spherical than the first stage. That might make reentering it a bit easier than if it had the shape of the first stage. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low_Earth_orbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low_Earth_orbit
- stcredzero 10y agoA better approximation to the 2nd stage's shape would be that of a cow. (If that made no sense, it's a variation on an old freshman physics joke.)
- jacquesm 10y agoYou're absolutely right, I totally got that wrong. Thank you for the correction.
- woodandsteel 10y agoOne thing I really like about HN as compared with many other web sites is it will often happen that someone will admit they were wrong.
- grecy 10y ago>I don't believe it's likely that we'll see recovery of an orbital velocity stage anytime soon. Oh, I wouldn't be so pessimistic. "Considering trying to bring upper stage back on Falcon Heavy demo flight for full reusability. Odds of success low, but maybe worth a shot." - Elon Musk [1] [1]https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/847882289581359104 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/847882289581359104 Remember, everyone said they would never land the first stage....
- vkou 10y ago> Remember, everyone said they would never land the first stage.... Everyone? That's a bit hyperbolic.
- dotancohen 10y agoActually almost everyone with experience in the matter said that SpaceX would never successfully reuse a first stage booster. That would be Boeing, USA, and a majority of NASA engineers. Granted many of those had an interest in seeing Space Exploration Technologies fail, but their opinion certainly holds weight.
- dotancohen 10y agoRemoved
- gozur88 10y ago"...maybe worth a shot" is a pretty thin reed upon which to hang your hopes. There are a lot of reasons to not return the second stage, business as well as technical.
- grecy 10y agoSure, I agree, though it's clear Elon has made a career out of the thin reeds. Also, if they don't do it now, it's obvious they are working on it / thinking about it. Wait five years.
- TylerE 10y agoThing is you just need heat shielding, really. A de-orbit burn well have a rather small dV, say, 50m/s or so. Then let the atmosphere do almost all the work... the stage just needs to survive, and then do a suicide burn landing just like the stage 1.
- rst 10y agoIf you're doing the suicide burn with the main engine, you have to flip inside the atmosphere (while supersonic), and also need to lose large chunks of the nozzle (not just to get it out of the way of landing legs, but because firing the engine in the atmosphere would otherwise generate turbulent flow within the nozzle which would tear the thing apart). If you're using a different engine, then you've added a whole lot of extra weight from the engine itself and its plumbing (and tankage for its fuels if, like the Dragon 2 Superdracos, it's not burning LOX and Kerosene). So, adapting the first-stage recovery strategy is not an obvious slam dunk -- in fact, it might very well be worth considering alternatives involving parachutes if you can get the thing intact through re-entry. (Note that the Falcon 9 v1.0 first stages on which they actually tried parachute recovery are believed to have not gotten that far -- they reportedly broke up before the parachutes even deployed.)
- TylerE 10y agoOh, I'm not saying it'd be easy, just that the dV needed to get the stage down is <<< the dV to get it up. The devil is in the details, of course.
- lutorm 10y agoWill, it's 1/16th the kinetic energy required for the stage to get to orbit, but not 1/16th of the total kinetic energy needed. Most of the s2 mass is fuel, of which very little is taken to orbital velocity.