4 ms·
Not sure you can think of it as good or bad. The government takes away rights from someone people and grants them to others. I have the right to own land and ma
by sharemywin 10y ago
Not sure you can think of it as good or bad. The government takes away rights from someone people and grants them to others. I have the right to own land and make it so you can't use it because "we the people say so." good for me, bad for you.
I guess there's a net win now that I think about it. I could have protected with a club. good for me, good for you because I didn't club you in the head.
- hbt 10y agoyour land is protected by a club. instead of protecting it yourself, you delegated the job to the government. libertarians will argue "why not delegate to a private company?" because we all learned from past experience. it is better for one entity to have a monopoly on violence than multiple small organizations.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> I guess there's a net win now that I think about it. I could have protected with a club. good for me, good for you because I didn't club you in the head. Yes, that's how it actually works. You have rights to some piece of land, I have rights to another, we don't step on each other's toes, and if we don't like the split, there are blood-free procedures to resolve disputes. More importantly, neither of us has to invest in clubs and constant vigilance, because we've outsourced that job. So we all save time, resources and effort. It's not perfect, but it's a useful tool in our toolbox for building societies.