3 ms·
I would agree with this, governments (western at least) have distorted the measurement of so many statistics (inflation in Canada is <2% because they essentiall
by mistermann 10y ago
I would agree with this, governments (western at least) have distorted the measurement of so many statistics (inflation in Canada is <2% because they essentially exclude housing costs, as if that's a minor part of a typical family's budget) that historical comparisons are a joke.
I've had a question about Japan for a long time I hope someone reading may have some insight:
The nature of the Japanese workplace and society is so unique on the planet, does anyone know if there has ever been an in-depth economic study trying to translate some of it into numbers?
For example, on one hand you have the negative economic effect of "overstaffing" (my word), or having employees doing really quite unnecessary (ignoring a variable increase in pleasantness) things. Or, staying until 10PM pretending to work. Both of these must hurt productivity numbers big time.
But on the other hand, Japan enjoys a relative lack of expenses for many societal ills like various crimes, welfare, drug abuse, etc which would to a degree cancel out the above expenses.
It's obviously very complex, but I wonder if anyone has ever made a competent attempt at putting some of this into numbers?
- randomdata 10y ago> inflation in Canada is <2% because they essentially exclude housing costs The practical month to month housing costs are included. Rent is an item in the basket of goods, as are mortgage payments, insurance payments, etc.[1] > as if that's a minor part of a typical family's budget What is missing is the "once in a lifetime" down payment made on the purchase of a home. But that happens so infrequently that it is difficult to see how spending changes over time. In terms of family budgeting it doesn't seem completely unreasonable to exclude it - you don't really need to budget for it. [1] http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/62-001-x/2017003/tbl/tbl-4-2-eng.htm http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/62-001-x/2017003/tbl/tbl-4-2-en...
- mistermann 10y agoReading that I can see how one might come to the wrong conclusion (that actual housing costs are what is used to calculate inflation), that is likely in fact the intent. The reality though is different: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/economy-lab/cpi-doesnt-fully-measure-household-inflation-and-it-wasnt-meant-to/article15551986/ http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/ec... Think about it: how can you have ~1% GDP growth, flat or diminishing wages, but housing prices (the largest purchase any family will ever make, 10+ years of salary) rising at 5% to 30% (in extreme cases) per year, year after year after year, with no drop in other spending categories, but somehow inflation is <2%? Where is the money coming from to drive this housing bubble? So what we have here is our government deliberately misleading us on incredibly important economic matters, that are massively distorting our economy and the economic behavior of individuals.
- randomdata 10y ago> Where is the money coming from to drive this housing bubble? A bubble constrained to a handful of specific markets within the country. Which, a common theme I hear is that people choose to live in those markets because their income is higher than if they lived elsewhere. It seems that the market is simply correcting on the expense side so that incomes between those locations and other parts of the country even out. If it were more lucrative to live elsewhere, people would. To put it another way, if, hypothetically, your expected revenue is $50,000/year in Toronto and $35,000/year in rural Manitoba, and your expenses are $20,000/year in each location, you have $15,000/year additional money that you can put into the Toronto housing market. On the other hand, if expenses rose to $45,000 in Toronto, then your income would actually be $10,000/year higher in rural Manitoba. You'd be hard-pressed to not consider moving for a $10,000/year raise. But the population of Toronto, and similar markets, keep on growing by leaps and bounds, which indicates that there is still extra money to be made there. Money that can eventually be spent on housing.
- Camillo 10y agoFunny how these spherical cow models of perfectly efficient and fungible markets end up justifying a huge and growing transfer of wealth from the productive part of the economy to pure (and literal) rent-seekers, which is perhaps the worst possible outcome for actual economic efficiency.
- mistermann 10y agoIf it was just Vancouver and Toronto that would be one thing, but housing across Canada (except perhaps the maritimes) has seen huge gains in the last decade, far beyond income growth. These price increases have been excluded from inflation (price inflation) numbers, as has the massive growth in consumer credit (monetary inflation). I don't have an article for you, but Canada has surpassed the US at the peak of their housing bubble in most any metric you look at, some of them substantially. Unsurprisingly, convincing anyone to acknowledge this reality is near impossible, the numbers can stare people in the face and they simple refuse to believe them.
- 10y ago