4 ms·
The argument about what "a real and physical wavefunction" means boils down to this question: "Is there a science of the wavefunction beyond QM?" Can you ask
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
The argument about what "a real and physical wavefunction" means boils down to this question:
"Is there a science of the wavefunction beyond QM?"
Can you ask more questions about it, break it down into constituent processes, maybe re-engineer it?
Or is it opaque and closed and there is no possible way to do further science on it?
My money is on option 1, because it's hard to imagine an organising principle you can't possibly do any science on.
Wavefunction science may be weird and like nothing ever seen before - especially given non-locality and possibly non-realism. But it's a good rule of thumb in science that when nature becomes counterintuitive you're on the right track. If the answer was obvious and familiar you wouldn't need original and creative thinking to find it.
Option 2 seems like an admission of total defeat. It would be the first time in science where we hit a wall and didn't even try to understand what it was made of.
That doesn't mean it can't be correct. But it does mean we shouldn't give up without trying for quite a while longer. And if we do give up, it should only be after discovering some kind of meta-Bell theorem which proves there's no way to go further.
- yters 10y agoIf I understand it all correctly, the article describes an experiment to test your preferred option, but so far the evidence is in favor of option 2?