6 ms·
this has been discussed here previously. tl;dr: he was fined, correctly, for claiming a professional licensure and authority to which he's not entitled. Not fo
by hprotagonist 10y ago
this has been discussed here previously.
tl;dr: he was fined, correctly, for claiming a professional licensure and authority to which he's not entitled. Not for "using math".
professional engineers are real in the same way board-licensed specialists or bar-admitted lawyers are, and you can't claim to be one unless you are one. end of story.
- astrodust 10y agoThis is why the term "software engineer" is very divisive.
- ghaff 10y agoNot really. But there are specific situations, e.g. signing off on things related to regulatory agencies, where PEs are required. Lots of engineers in a variety of engineering professions have no need for PEs but some do.
- GavinMcG 10y agoKeep in mind that "not really" may be dependent on where you're at. It is divisive in some places. More so Europe than the United States.
- ghaff 10y agoFair enough. In the US, "engineer" is used pretty widely--including by people who are clearly not engineers. (I could name a number of examples from the oil business.) PEs are mostly about certifications needed to sign off on things in some cases. I got an Engineer-in-Training certificate but never had the need to get a PE.
- strictnein 10y agoStrangely, the first software dev title I got with "Engineer" in the title was from a European company. "Applications Engineer"
- nialo 10y agoThis may be a reason why, but it's not a great one. The vast majority of people employed in the US with "engineer" in their job title are not Professional Engineers.
- ClearAsMud 10y agoYa, it's just a made up title to make people feel important, to be honest.
- ghaff 10y agoIt's a professional certification. You can argue about how much significance it has but it's certainly not "made up."
- ClearAsMud 10y agoI'm talking about folks that call themselves engineers, where they clearly are not. A PE has an exam with credential requirements and an apprenticeship under another PE for a period of time + having to retake that PE exam in order to get that designation. I COMPLETELY understand the PE part of it. It's the software developers that use the title of engineer that irks me. Or HR folks baiting software developers with a title of "engineer" when they clearly are NOT qualified to be that - both by credentials or by the PE designation. Engineers are engineers, scientists are scientists (and equally less qualified in comparison to engineers). Are scientists important? Absolutely .. for me, it's more about the semantics of use and the validation of it.
- ghaff 10y agoWell, good luck with that. Back when I was in the oil business, there were even mud engineers--or mud salesmen as the toolpushers called them. I certainly don't favor the idea that every software engineer/consulting engineer/etc. should have to get a PE before they can call themselves by that title. You're welcome to feel differently but don't expect a lot of support.
- 10y ago
- ClearAsMud 10y agoSee, it's not divisive at all to me. There are two types of degrees - a computer science degree and a computer engineering degree. If you are an engineer - your paper says so. If you are a scientist ... you are a scientist. There is a very BIG difference. Folks that write software can be both engineers and scientists. However, there are key differences in the applications of being an engineer. Just because I write E=mc^2 on a board and apply it to some problem in front of me, doesn't make me a theoretical physicist - it just makes me a guy writing on a board, a formula that a physicist might use. In the case of the story, he's a mechanical "engineer". He isn't a guy off the street calling himself an engineer. He has the education to match the claim. HUGE difference. Software engineers have degrees that state they are. Software / computer scientist can be thrown around more liberally, but a software ENGINEER cannot.
- strictnein 10y agoSoftware engineers would typically have Computer Science degrees, not Computer Engineering degrees.
- ClearAsMud 10y agoSoftware engineers w/o degrees are just software developers. They are not engineers, by any stretch of the term. Engineering principals applied to software, including performance analysis and validation are done by engineers. There is a big difference. Actually a HUGE difference. This isn't most likely going to be popular here, because a lot of industry folks who are in the epicenter of SF just like the title more than the job .. but it's fact, IMHO. I don't mind having discrediting titles all the time, but it's more ego that pushes it. I could care less about a title, so I'll call it out all the time. Scientists are not engineers.
- strictnein 10y ago> "but it's fact, IMHO" That's not how facts work.
- aphistic 10y ago
- icantdrive55 10y agoI image the states will realize this industry could be licensed eventually, and the extra fees will make the states very happy. Just imagine having to pass a dubious test, or become certified before calling yourself a Programmer, or Website whatever? Paying the state for a licence, completing mandatory education, and dubious work experience, carrying a bond, and disclosing where they can sent a suppona. Fun times ahead? Those licence fees are getting high too. It's all on the name of consumer safety though? I pay $180 plus $90 if I'm a day late for a inactive contractor's licence. Why does the state charge people for an inactive licence? I can't use it? It's a money grab. Yes--"Engineer" is a grey area. The one that really bother me was when the Realtor's Lobbiests made it more difficult to become a broker. I remember Gov. Schwartzeneger saw right through the ploy, and said no to the new changes. After all selling realestate is eight courses, common sence, omission and errors insurance(optional), and a bond. It's not rocket science. Governor Brown let the Realtors have their way, and there's fewer Brokers in California; reducing competition. Yea!
- gonzo 10y agoHe didn't claim a P.E. he said he was "an excellent engineer" in an email.
- hprotagonist 10y agoseparate to his email about traffic lights, his website offers his services as an engineering consultant. that's a major no-no. he was warned twice and then got a slap on the wrist after he did it again after saying he wouldn't. edit: and yes actually, saying you're "an engineer" in an email to the state traffic board _is_ claiming a PE when you don't have one.
- snowwindwaves 10y agohttp://www.jarlstrom.com/index.html http://www.jarlstrom.com/index.html has his website changed? It doesn't say professional engineer anywhere on it.
- hprotagonist 10y agoThe language here: http://www.jarlstrom.com/consulting_.htm http://www.jarlstrom.com/consulting_.htm particularly advertisement of services as an expert witness, etc, all are problematic under oregon law. In particular, you cannot be an expert witness without being a PE. They go into this in the complaint PDF with relevant sections of law, etc.
- ghaff 10y agoI don't know Oregon law specifically but I've been an expert witness and don't have a PE.
- wtallis 10y ago>particularly advertisement of services as an expert witness, etc, all are problematic under oregon law. In particular, you cannot be an expert witness without being a PE. > They go into this in the complaint PDF with relevant sections of law, etc. None of the quoted regulations in the complaint mention being an expert witness or even use either of those words.