3 ms·
I'm not surprised when the Brookings Institute concludes that the answer is less regulation. The article ignores the market dynamics of real-estate development
by brudgers 10y ago
I'm not surprised when the Brookings Institute concludes that the answer is less regulation.
The article ignores the market dynamics of real-estate development. Those dynamics are created by the the limited fungibility of real property. Real property may be exchanged for cash, but following such a transaction the cash can not (usually) be used to replace the original property because there is only one property at a particular location.
In general, real-estate development seeks to maximize profits by pushing parcels toward their highest and best use. Removing regulations affecting real-estate entitlement won't change the economics affecting what developers build. Class A office space will be more profitable than a used car lot. A Porsche dealership will be more profitable than a Greyhound station. Luxury apartments will be more profitable than a tenement. Those are what developers will try to build.
Suppose a luxury housing developer controls a parcel, removing entitlement regulations does not mean the developer builds a tenement. It means either the luxury housing developer builds luxury housing or waits until there is demand for luxury housing or someone makes an offer on the parcel that meets the luxury housing developer's expected internal rate of return from developing the property as luxury housing. An affordable housing developer who wants the parcel has to pay the price of a parcel suitable for luxury housing to obtain it. So will another luxury housing developer or an office building developer and for them the price will make more economic sense.
One way of thinking about real-estate is that each and every parcel is a monopoly. Some monopolies are worth more than others. Removing entitlement regulations does not change the value of locations. It does not change the economic incentives of highest and best use. It does not remove market demand.