9 ms·
Microsoft phone revenue fell to $5M last quarter, from $1.4B two years ago
- Joeri 10y agoPhone hardware was always a bad fit for microsoft. They always saw it as a vehicle for making a platform play, but to make good phones you have to see it as an end unto itself. The phone is the business you are in, not the platform that the phone happens to run on.
- mtgx 10y agoAgreed that Microsoft saw it more as an accessory to Windows PCs, at least early on. However, ultimately WP lost because it was too late. iOS and Android were too much ahead. Exactly why it was such a catastrophic mistake for Nokia to go with WP over Android "because it was different." Not saying that Android would've necessarily saved Nokia's crown in the smartphone market, or even saved it as a company, but I do think it would've been a smarter strategic play than going with WP. And the only reason I'm even saying that is because Nokia did a ton of mistakes on its own, before it even had to make that choice - like waiting until it was too late to make the decision, or neglecting the Maemo platform, and so on.
- ptaipale 10y agoActually, Nokia as a company is doing rather well. Just the handset business was rebooted.
- mee_too 10y agoActually Nokia market cap is 30G, while Apple's 750G, 90% of which is "the handset business".
- ptaipale 10y agoSure, but a 30G company is still not exactly small.
- mee_too 10y agoNokia's cap was 300G at one time, it was bigger than Apple when the iPhone came out and it was the leader on the booming smartphone market. They lost a lot of value, fired a lot of people, lost their biggest market - which is not "doing rather well" for a publicly traded business ...
- Ologn 10y agoAlso, Nokia didn't have to choose between Microsoft and Google. They could have done both, like Samsung did. In terms of attracting programmers, Android could be programmed on Mac, Windows or Linux. A developer account was a one-time fee of $25. Apps needed no approval. Windows Phone had to be programmed on Windows. A developer account cost $100 a year or so. Apps went through an approval process. Not that different than Apple, but Apple was first to market with a modern smartphone and could get away with this.
- mee_too 10y agoNokia couldn't do what Samsung did. They lacked factories for NANDs, CPUs, RAM, screens, camera sensors.
- ptaipale 10y agoI think Nokia could have done both Symbian and Maemo and even something else still (if the leadership had not been complacent). But that is all water under the bridge.
- mee_too 10y agoThey tried to improve Symbian - I've got their latest and greatest Symbian device, the 808 and it's a joke. Even if they could do Maemo, there would've been no apps - Microsoft failed to attract enough devs, given that there were already 10M .NET devs out there.
- hadrien01 10y agoI'm really sad, because Windows Phone 8.1 was a really good OS, and Nokia made good and beautiful phones. But Microsoft never seemed to care much about the OS; they didn't market it well, and some basic functionality was missing five years in, when they were quite advanced at the beginning.
- bostand 10y agoI think they did care, they just couldn't get it right. Just look how horribly buggy w10m has been despite months of patching and bug fixing.
- MiddleEndian 10y agoThey made some conscious and poor design choices in w10m. They decided to copy Android in a bunch of weird ways, too many notifications and inconsistent keyboard behavior.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vezycash 10y ago12 reasons WP died. Ms-Nokia actively sabotaged/tripped WP on every step. 1. Charging $100 yearly developer fee was crazy. ESP since they were the incumbent and Google was charging a one-time fee of $49 if memory serves me. 2. MS decision not to allow sideloading of apps basically killed their chances outside US, UK, Germany... - places without cheap broadband. Even IOS allowed for apps to be downloaded on a computer. Many of my potential WP converts ran to Android for this very reason. AFAIK, MS has issues increasing Store usage on Win10 in my country because store apps installation files can't be stored offline. 3. API limitations - if the initial developer fee put a nail on the coffin. This was the hammer that drove it home. A lot of developers simply quit and focused on android. The few who persisted habitually wrote messages like, "...feature cannot be done due to a limitation in the OS" 4. Speed - if Bill was in charge, WP would be hale & hearty right now. Ballmer and his people took their sweet time before adding new features - as if they were competing with resourceless startups or stagnant giants. Thousands of feature requests flooded Nokia forum, the ln user voice - only for a handful to be added a year and six months later. E.g. Notification area, file manager, folders, led notification, wifi direct 5. Apple worship - IMO WP was Microsoft's first attempt to out-Apple Apple on design. Win8 was the second and Surface was the third. They forgot to notice that Apple never copied blindly - copying the spirit of a design or feature - Apple STOLE. Since WP, win8..10 all that matters to Ms is looks and pays lip service usability & productivity. 6. Nokia released too many phones with nonsensical, confusing naming. They released flagships with 2 year old processors. And randomly removed features available in low range phones from high/mid range phones and vice versa. 7. Nokia att exclusives killed more sales than they would ever know. 8. Ms/Nokia focused too much on the US market. In fact, Ms behaves as if only US market exists. Cortana spent more than a year as a US exclusive. Till today, some Bing features are US only. 9. Marketing - MS simply didn't market the OS. Nokia - a hardware partner did 100x more marketing than ever MS. 10. Selling the OS - selling the OS free for the first 2 years would have bought them many partners esp since Android was free. 11. Platform reboot - wp7, wp8, Wp8.1, wp10. Every reboot inflicted a deep wound on fans, OEMs and the OS. This reboot issue plagues Skype as well. I remember at least 4 reboots of skype on WP. 12. Nadella - he buried WP.
- bostand 10y agoWell, you can't have revenue if you have nothing to sell. No new phones + removing old ones from stores means no sells.
- morganvachon 10y agoThat's what I can't understand. Why even buy Nokia if there was no intention of continuing to manufacture phones a few years later? If they had released three new phones (low end, mid tier, flagship) in February 2017 they would have at least kept up with previous earnings. If the flagship model (and perhaps even the mid tier) were released as the rumored "Surface" models and specced appropriately, they would likely have seen a small increase initially and greater sales as the year goes on. Instead, we get more advertising and less privacy than before, in Windows 10 on the desktop. I'm done, Microsoft.
- bpicolo 10y agoI wonder if they aren't hoping to leverage React Native's growth to expand the platform's app offerings (eventually). The real problem is that innovation in the mobile space has just stagnated. It was a 10-year explosive all-in from Apple and Google and the winners are kinda just in place now. The industry happened very quickly. I don't see a compelling reason for consumers to jump ship unless something big actually comes about (why would they?)
- Theodores 10y agoI don't understand it, there should be a customer base for managed rather than BYOD devices where a Microsoft device should be mandatory, as per Blackberry in earlier times. Although not a huge market compared to the mainstream iOS/Android world this market could make enough money to support three or four devices that do a good job of running Microsoft things. Such devices need not be marketed as 'phones' but more as 'Pocket Office', so you have a gadget that completely connects you to work doing things like Office and Outlook properly, a deluxe experience. Remote desktop should also be a thing so your 'Pocket Office' can be just another desktop window, with Synergy style copy and paste. It would not have been that hard for them to have got that seamless experience right, to not care about regular phone apps and just deliver the experience their corporate customers would want, with endpoints of their network fully locked down. Surface has proven that MS can sell decent hardware to companies, they should have done the same with the phone even if the market was to be a new 'Pocket Office' one rather than a 'smartphone' one.
- soneca 10y agoI thought there was an anouncement. I had Nokias all my life and my two first smartphones were Windows Phone and I was pretty happy about it. I still prefer WP "tile" UI, better use of space and informative home screen. Especially for my use case, as I don't like handling tens of apps and 95% of my use was email, browser, Whatsapp, podcasts, online banking, and Twitter. But then Microsoft effectively announced it quit. After MS signaled it, you could see even the biggest companies (Facebook and Twitter, my bank) started to neglect their WP apps. So that was the end. Now my third smartphone is a Moto G4 Android. I still prefer the 'tile' UI, but I am changing my user profile. I use many more apps now, like Reddit and an app for a brazilian website. Not essential, but ok. But having the newest features early on Whatsapp and a proper banking app are a much better experience.
- epmaybe 10y agoThere are Windows 10 launchers for Android that are decent. Not exactly the same, but you might like it more than I did.
- gesman 10y agoBallmer's "me too!" but always late for the party legacy.
- criddell 10y agoLate? Windows Mobile pre-dates iOS by 5 years. It's interesting that their first attempts were shrinking desktop Windows UI to work on a phone. That failed so they came up with a phone UI and expanded it to work on the desktop. What's the third act?
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoYes but Windows Mobile was awful, the reason Apple did so well with the iPhone was that the rest of the industry had stagnated.
- dageshi 10y agoIt was the same as all Microsoft products, it was aimed at businesses primarily where they could leverage all the features that come with a Microsoft domain e.g. Exchange integration. I worked at a Housing Association (UK) and we issued all our tradesmen with Windows Mobile smartphones. They received & completed all their jobs via a custom app we wrote for it, all pre iPhone. Microsoft has never been a company that targets consumers directly in my opinion, they're a company that targets business first and foremost and due to network effects they effectively got most of the consumer desktop market as well.
- dep_b 10y agoSo why exactly do we have a crippled desktop experience in Windows 10 now? Because it needed to look like a platform that effectively doesn't exist anymore? And I like Windows Phone a lot. Perfect for people that just wanted a simple phone with decent support.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y ago> So why exactly do we have a crippled desktop experience in Windows 10 now? We don't? Can you clarify what you're referring to?
- thiht 10y agoI don't get why you're being downvoted, I find the Windows 10 experience to be excellent on desktop and on the Surface. I get that some people might disagree with this, but could they at least care to explain why instead of downvoting?
- catmanjan 10y agoI think the desktop is more closely related to the tablet platform than mobiles.
- avaer 10y agoSurface still exists. And there's still warts in the uncanny valley between mouse and touch, but I wouldn't call Windows 10 crippled. I'm more puzzled at UX problems in OSX, where there isn't the excuse of having to support hundreds of vendors.
- dugditches 10y agoI recently got an older Surface Pro 1st gen. And it came with Windows 8.1. And I reminded how awful the UI was compared to 10. That mix between Tablet/Touch and Desktop, when Microsoft was in a very pigheaded way. The true 'crippled' nature of Windows 10 isn't the UI. It's the intrusive always on Updates, Apps, ads on your desktop, popups on your lockscreen, etc that 'cripple' it.
- 10y ago
- Paul_S 10y ago... and no one really noticed. Microsoft could do the sensible thing and sell Android phones.
- lenkite 10y agoI really, really liked my Nokia Windows phone. The tile based UI, the smooth performance and snappy UX, an excellent camera and the way the battery could last for sometimes 3 whole days without charging. Android phones just don't compare. And though I like MacOS, I could never get iOS. Microsoft gave up the war here in the last 10%. They should have put their head down and persisted. Alas, now we just have two flavors of phone..
- bb101 10y agoTry a Blackberry KeyOne when it's released in May. It runs the latest version of Android without any lags, has a physical keyboard for simple use (shortcuts for everything), has the same camera as the Google Pixel (v.good) and packs a 3500mAh battery that will last more than a day with moderate use. I'm using one now and it's nothing short of excellent.
- bitmapbrother 10y agoIt may use the same sensor as the Pixel, but it doesn't have the Pixel camera processing algorithms. Those Pixel algorithms are a big reason why it's considered to have the best smartphone camera.
- theNewMicrosoft 10y agoPersisted = Burn millions of $ because some insignificant minuscule minority happens to like their phones.
- MarkCole 10y agoThe minority that likes their phones may be miniscule in comparison to say the iPhone. But in the phone market a small market share can still equal billions a year. There is room for them to carve out a niche of Microsoft Phones earning them a couple of billion in revenue, and a couple of hundred million in profit. However for a big company like Microsoft that money is a drop in the ocean, and they want to own the market which at this point in time is unrealistic for them unless they can produce something truely groundbreaking.
- pentae 10y agoWhat's really sad is how they took Nokia down in flames with them. I'm really looking forward to seeing HMD Global rise Nokia out of the ashes - the new 3310 is a great start but without 3G/4G LTE support is DOA. Lots of countries don't even have the old 2G spectrums anymore. That being said, if I was Samsung i'd be very concerned about the new Android powered Nokia phones hitting the market.
- BoorishBears 10y agoI have no idea why I keep hearing doom and gloom over the lack of 3G/4G on the new 3310 when it's marketed towards countries where the original 3310 isn't an uncommon second phone...
- sweden 10y agoAside from the lack of security from the 2G networks, not to mention the worse quality call, it is very likely that 2G will be phase out during the next decade in many countries. This will render the phone utterly useless.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pentae 10y agoPrecisely because it limits it to specific markets you mentioned. The new 3310 got a ton of press in the US/AU/EU etc and lots of people like myself would love to buy one as a second phone. In a lot of places such as Singapore the 2G network is already phased out. It's a huge missed opportunity.
- Markoff 10y agohow is it different from any other Nokia feature phone? i still don't get what's so special about this 3310 compared to other legendary cheap models of Nokia which they produced in recent years like 1100, except ripoff name
- open-source-ux 10y agoIt's a shame to say goodbye to Windows Phone (WP), although it's not surprising. I have a Windows phone and think the Windows Phone OS is probably the best thing that Microsoft has designed. Their desktop apps and operating systems have a reputation for being clunky and clumsy to use (which I agree with), but Windows Phone (starting with version 7) was a surprisingly well-designed mobile operating system. Yes, WP lacked features compared to Android and iOS, but that simplicity was also arguably a strength (although they started over-complicating the home screen in Windows Phone 10 in my opinion). The other nice thing about Windows Phone was that it was actually different from both Android and iOS. That too made for a refreshing change. Instead of the generic grid-of-icons approach, you had tiles of different sizes that could display app updates. Finally, I was impressed by the visual design philosophy behind Windows Phone when it first launched. The designers took inspiration from wayfinding and airport and metro signage. That made sense for a mobile phone - you quickly glance at your phone multiple times a day, often while you're on the move. You need clear, large type to make this easy. The designers seemed to have purposefully chosen to emphasize type for this reason over the more icon-based approach of iOS and Android, although this sadly seemed to diminish somewhat with Windows Phone 10.
- wwayer 10y agoMy thoughts, exactly. Thank you for putting them in to words.
- skdotdan 10y agoMobile is an obvious existential threat to Microsoft.
- acjohnson55 10y agoI always thought if MS can make Windows Phone run Android apps in a seamless way, there's hope for it.
- beagle3 10y agoThey tried to and gave up; the subsystem that runs Linux user mode programs originated from that work though.
- revjx 10y agoI had Windows phones for a few years - Windows 7 & 8. I moved to Android with a Nexus 5X, but still had fond memories of Windows phone. It was a limited but snappy little platform. My Pixel is off for repair at the moment so I've had to revert to the Lumia 735. I've upgraded it to Windows 10. It's awful. The UI is sluggish, apps take over 30 seconds to load in some cases (Messenger and Whatsapp being key culprits), and it just generally feels counter-intuitive to use. I'm hating every second of using it.
- wslh 10y agoI think in a few years you could have a mobile phone transformed into a notebook, like the Microsoft Surface but smaller. In this context Windows phones can get some traction again. Indeed I think it is possible right now but nobody is offering a good transformation. There is a company that is promising this but until today never launched the product.
- Animats 10y agoSo Microsoft went to all that trouble to make Windows look like a phone screen, forcing an inappropriate AI onto laptops and desktops, then blew it in the phone business. How's Microsoft's "Surface" thing doing?
- qohen 10y ago> How's Microsoft's "Surface" thing doing? Recent iterations of Microsoft's Surface tablets seem to be doing well [0]: In those early days, the Surface was looking less like an Xbox-style home run for Microsoft, and more a Zune -like fiasco. But that's all ancient history -- call it the Ballmerzoic Era. The 2014 Surface Pro 3 became what Microsoft always hoped it would be: the flagship device for touch computing on Windows, the go-to alternative for those who wanted both a tablet and a laptop without feeling shortchanged on either front. The Surface Pro 4 refines the hardware formula even further, and with Windows 10 on board rather than Windows 8, the platform's final big compromise evaporates too. Now, the Surface line is the design leader: Apple's upcoming iPad Pro and Google's Pixel C tablets are the ones aping Microsoft's design, adding snap-on keyboards and ramping up the multitasking chops of their touch-first operating systems. [0] https://www.cnet.com/uk/products/microsoft-surface-pro-4/review/ https://www.cnet.com/uk/products/microsoft-surface-pro-4/rev...
- thr0waway1239 10y agoI wonder if Microsoft is a welcome competitor in those domains where they don't have any monopolistic advantage. They will help you avoid any anti-trust issues, while also being too sluggish/dysfunctional to actually execute.
- HenryBemis 10y agoAnd in one simple meme: [1]: http://s2.quickmeme.com/img/37/37b0641f1cb0ae77dc9b8fc8c84582543f16183b4745a5de1dbb0559473bb3e9.jpg http://s2.quickmeme.com/img/37/37b0641f1cb0ae77dc9b8fc8c8458...
- codecamper 10y agoVery good! I can cross off a platform from the stuff to learn list.
- Old_Thrashbarg 10y agoI had assumed Microsoft had given up on its phone ambitions, so was surprised to see a Microsoft phone product placement while watching the new movie "Get Out" last night.
- combatentropy 10y agoMicrosoft has always been just a mediocre software company led by salesmen. Their extraordinary success on the desktop depended too much on being in the right place at the right time. That serendipity didn't happen for them with phones and likely won't happen again for anything else. They must compete with the other companies on merit, and they will do so with great mediocrity. Plus, they now are getting a taste of their own medicine in having to compete with companies that are entrenched, which may not always be better technically but have the momentum going for them.
- chrismealy 10y agoI knew people in Redmond who were working on mobile in 1995. Being first is not always a good thing.