3 ms·
Perhaps too political for HN, but anyawy... I can't understand Labor's plan. They seem to be going out of their way to alienate everyone who is attracted to vo
by nl 16y ago
Perhaps too political for HN, but anyawy...
I can't understand Labor's plan. They seem to be going out of their way to alienate everyone who is attracted to voting for them.
They have lost the green vote by dropping the emissions trading scheme.
They have lost the "doctors wives" (see last election) with their refugee policy.
They have lost most political progressives with the internet filter and now this plan.
Even the unions aren't 100% behind them because of the impact of the Super Profit Tax policy.
I can understand that they think that they might lose primary votes to the Greens, say, and then regain them via preferences. But it seems to me that many people are getting to the point where they think that even Tony Abbot couldn't be as bad as this.
(Disclaimer: I'm Australian)
- Andys 16y agoMore importantly, Tony Abbot is what he says he is, which makes him more charismatic than Ruddbot.
- philk 16y agoUsing the phrase "is what he says he is" to describe a politician who admitted to lying during an interview on a major nightly news program strikes me as a rather creative interpretation of reality. Luckily for him actually being honest and consistent is an absolute irrelevance, all he needs to do is give the appearance of being a straight up guy.
- tomhoward 16y agoAdmitted to lying! Yep, the ones who don't admit it are far preferable :) He admitted explicitly to doing what every politician does, what everyone knows they do, and what Lindsay Tanner did only hours later on the ABC. It was an unfortunate, clumsy thing to say, but the "gotcha" triumphalism should be reserved for people who don't admit to their failings, not the ones who do.
- nl 16y agoKevin Rudd isn't charismatic, but that doesn't particularly matter to me.
- hugh3 16y agoCharismatic is the wrong word. Australians, thankfully, have a distaste of charismatic leaders. Any Australian politician who tried to make grand Obama-style orations would find himself unable to finish due to the giggles coming from the audience.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- brc 16y agoI think it comes down to the personality of Rudd and his need to keep an iron grip on the government. He's got a filthy mouth and temper as shown on several occasions, and he develops all his policies in combination with just 4 ministers. The fact that the (former) environment minister found out about the dropping of the ETS via the newspaper tells you how centralised the decision making is. Same goes for the mining tax ; developed in secret, behind closed doors and out it comes with a 'my way or the highway' attitude. My point : I don't think they know what they are doing. They look very similar to the misguided wanderings of the last 12 months of the Howard government.