5 ms·
Maybe losing the current web wouldn't be that bad, it's largely become a centralised, tracking and surveillance tool for mass marketing and used for spying on c
by bamboozled 10y ago
Maybe losing the current web wouldn't be that bad, it's largely become a centralised, tracking and surveillance tool for mass marketing and used for spying on citizens. One gets the feeling that any significant level of "openness" died a long time ago.
It's not that it's useless, but a fresh start might not be the worst outcome.
- myowncrapulence 10y agoThis is exactly why an entirely encrypted internet would be desirable. ISP's won't be able to track or throttle since they won't know who's connecting to what.
- studentrob 10y agoThat would stifle development in its own way. We haven't repealed net neutrality yet. Let's keep at it and see where this goes.
- gregmac 10y agoOr your ISP would just MITM everything and provide their own CA you must accept to use their service.
- topranks 10y agoIt would need to be like TOR - if you just encrypted then they'd see who you were talking to, just not what you're saying.
- darkkindness 10y ago> a fresh start might not be the worst outcome. The article gave the implication of having a locked-down internet reminiscent of China's -- losing net neutrality doesn't necessarily mean losing this centralized, tracking and surveillance tool for mass marketing and spying. I would love to hear your definition of 'fresh start'.
- nebabyte 10y agoI'm guessing they're holding out for a meshnet. Less realistically likely to be implemented at scale (and scale is what makes the internet as wonderful as it is) anytime soon than uber's moonshot of building their autonomous fleet in time tbh Also even if that is it it would solve nothing, [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14220269 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14220269
- bamboozled 10y agoDe-centralised models such as IPFS [1] seem promising. Mesh networks sound perfect for local / focused communities to keep in touch. Fresh start may have been the wrong wording, how about fresh approach? Rather than just settling for what we have, begin experimenting with new technological approaches and new architectures in the hope what we have can rework what we have now, drastically. Moving to better more open models. It's odd how quickly technology moves in other fields except not much has changed with regards to how the world builds and consumes the Internet over the last few decades, this lack of progress might be deliberate as it's in clearly certain groups interest to have it this way. [1] https://ipfs.io/ https://ipfs.io/
- studentrob 10y agoThis is also discussed elsewhere in this thread. Why reinvent the wheel just to get around people who are messing up the old wheel? Plus, any new network is susceptible to the same sort of lobbying and moneyed interests plaguing the existing internet. We will need to be forever vigilant in order to maintain our right to have equal access to data. Some have noted that even a constitutional amendment guaranteeing net neutrality rights could be rolled back, since that has precedent under rolling back prohibition.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"Plus, any new network is susceptible to the same sort of lobbying and moneyed interests plaguing the existing internet." BOOM! If corrupt politicians are the problem, then they'll be the problem no matter what you do if it threatens the interests of incumbents paying them. So, you have to fight the real battle.
- transposed 10y agoThe article got me thinking what might happen in a dystopian future where all networks are under tight control and surveillance. Well, there's already the dark web... But what about the physical "backbone" to support a world wide web? Could you do it without laying thousands of miles of fiber optic cable? And without flooding the radio spectrum?
- topranks 10y agoNo you couldn't.
- astrobe_ 10y agoIt's still fine if you don't use the modern multimedia interactive Internet, that needs a large bandwidth and big data centers, and therefore big companies and therefore questionable monetization schemes. Roll back to the nineties, when most of the traffic was made of text, and then a Cuban network is good enough. But of course, you have to say goodbye to Netflix and Youtube. That's not a bad thing. When I was a student in the nineties, I decided I wouldn't have a TV or a computer in my room, because those where too distracting for me. So I ended up reading books and listening to radio. The radio is a wonderful thing. It doesn't monopolize your primary sense. Making content doesn't require as much resources as for the TV. They don't need makeup. They don't need lighting. As a result they can focus more on the meaningful content. They just can't distract people with spectacular or pretty images anyway (even ads are better, because it's kind of difficult to sell stuff with boobs here). But don't hope too much. People won't go back in the nineties. YouTube and Facebook not being available is a no-go for them. Net neutrality and openness will be undone piece by piece over time. But if you're OK with going back to the BBS era (or the too short Gopher era), the bandwidth you'd use would be so tiny compared to the rest that the Internet giants won't care about you.
- studentrob 10y ago> But of course, you have to say goodbye to Netflix and Youtube. That's not a bad thing. When I was a student in the nineties, I decided I wouldn't have a TV or a computer in my room, because those where too distracting for me. So I ended up reading books and listening to radio Media is what you make it. Parents once viewed radio and books as distractions too. Fact is, the internet is loaded with free, useful educational content. The availability of that to anyone who has an internet connection is threatened by rolling back net neutrality.