4 ms·
Pass through entities means the entity doesn't pay taxes, it's owners do. And they always pay at personal income tax rates, so 39% for the high earners. This "l
by valuearb 10y ago
Pass through entities means the entity doesn't pay taxes, it's owners do. And they always pay at personal income tax rates, so 39% for the high earners. This "loophole" exists today, again you have to pay yourself a reasonable salary but most sole proprietorships and tightly held (like family owned) businesses are structured this way.
Either the author is confused about pass through entities, or I am confused about Trump's proposal, because I'm thought it only affects C corps, not pass through entities.
Edit: OK, I've re-read it and it was my confusion. The author is claiming that S corp owners want lower taxes if C corp owners get them, and the author is entirely correct that would be a huge loophole.
What he doesn't say clearly enough is it's ridiculous on it's face, pass through entities don't get double taxed already, and because C corps are double taxed they and their shareholders will still pay as much if not more taxes than the shareholders of passthrough entities with similar levels of income. C corps will still pay on average 20% given state taxes, combined with state and federal taxes on dividends their high income shareholders will certainly pay over 40% combined.
In CA a highest bracket taxpayer receiving dividends from a C corp would pay 10% State Corporate, 15% Federal, 13% State income, 20% federal dividend, or 47% total taxes on every dollar of profit. If their business is an S corp, they'd pay 13% state taxes, and 39% federal, which works out to a nearly identical 47% rate. But for the S Corp, no one pays 39% on all their income, as I wrote above they only pay around 28% on their first $400k, so again the pass through entity is going to be lower tax than a C corp even with Trumps proposed tax cut.
For example, if you made $1M after deductions, you would pay $350k in federal income tax, or 35% even though you were deep in the 39% bracket, even at the top CA tax rate your total income taxes would be around 44% with a pass-through. Significantly less than a C corp with Trump's 15% rate.
- maxerickson 10y agoThere have definitely been remarks about applying the proposal to pass throughs. I don't think it is really all that interesting of a discussion because the plan isn't fleshed out enough. In any case, they do have the goal of substantially altering the tax system, I guess what we have now isn't necessarily instructive about the shape it will take.