3 ms·
> “I have often been disappointed,” he writes of other facial data sets. “The datasets tend to be extremely strict in their structure, and are usually too small
by danso 10y ago
> “I have often been disappointed,” he writes of other facial data sets. “The datasets tend to be extremely strict in their structure, and are usually too small. Tinder gives you access to thousands of people within miles of you. Why not leverage Tinder to build a better, larger facial dataset?”
This guy sounds like a caricature of the exact kind of socially unaware techie who blithely implements dystopian-powering software, because having data and writing code is all that matters apparently. Privacy law admittedly isn't the simplest concept but you have to wonder how blissfully solipsistic someone has to be to write a simple script that scrapes proprietary data without asking himself, "this is so easy, I wonder why no one else has had this idea?"
And then he released the data under CC0, just to add insult to injury by making CC look unethical.
- SkyMarshal 10y agoCC aside (which I'm not sure he has the right to release Tinder's data under any arbitrary license of his choosing, CC or otherwise), I'm actually ok with security and privacy vulnerabilities being openly exposed in this way. Some random hacker in his garage figures out how to do it and just does, and makes it completely public. The general public is so complacent about this stuff, it feels like events like this, or the fappening, motivate them far more than most advocacy does, while doing far less harm than a govt agency using it in secret could.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIt's all fun and games until you violate the CFAA. Laws you may not like are still there to be enforced.
- joshumax 10y agoNow I feel bad for doing this exact thing with Tinder to create a data-set for determining age based on facial features... At least I didn't publicize it after and removed it when I was done
- _pmf_ 10y ago> This guy sounds like a caricature of the exact kind of socially unaware techie who blithely implements dystopian-powering software, because having data and writing code is all that matters apparently. Zuck?
- thr0waway1239 10y agoNo. He is a billionaire, which obviously means he is a visionary. These characterizations only apply to mere mortals and other dumb fucks such as those who contribute to Facebooks' MAU numbers.
- danso 10y agoWorth pointing out that Zuckerberg's obliviousness was very much like the guy featured in the OP, and he was punished for FaceMash and apologized for it [0]. He then created TheFacebook as an alternative to Harvard's online facebook, which was purportedly in development. The official facebook was taking longer because of worries about scraping of user information [1]: > Davis said that the principle complication with the creation of an official facebook was figuring out how to design an interface so that directory information could not easily be compiled without authorization. That said, Zuckerberg's TheFacebook got around that because students apparently were happy to upload their information to his service. And the rest is history. [0] http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2003/11/4/hot-or-not-website-briefly-judges/ http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2003/11/4/hot-or-not-websi... [1] http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2004/2/9/hundreds-register-for-new-facebook-website/ http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2004/2/9/hundreds-register...
- necessity 10y agoWhen I upload my photos to Tinder or Facebook I assume they are stored forever and may be used for any purpose by anyone. Any person who assumes otherwise is a fool.
- danso 10y agoYou would be wrong. Uploading your photo to a commercial service that is publicly accessible does not allow someone or anyone else to use your photo for other commercial purposes, such as in an advertisement, without a model release [0]. The rules governing consent and data of human subjects are even more stringent in academia, hence the existence of institutional review boards. [0] http://adland.tv/content/virgin-uses-cc-licenced-flickr-photo-ad-campaign-forgets-model-release-gets-sued http://adland.tv/content/virgin-uses-cc-licenced-flickr-phot...
- devrandomguy 10y agoDoes this apply internationally? Also, how would you know if your photo is being used commercially? What if the EULA of every major social network and photo sharing service, grants that service ownership and commercial usage of all of the content that you create with them?
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> What if the EULA of every major social network and photo sharing service, grants that service ownership and commercial usage of all of the content that you create with them? Courts would consider it an overreach, and that specific clause would be nullified. You can't take everything from another party while offering no compensation and expect a court to uphold it. EDIT: Disclaimer: Not a lawyer. Not your lawyer.
- devrandomguy 10y agoI know you didn't intend that as legal advice, but I sure hope that you are correct nonetheless. From the article: > It’s also worth noting that in agreeing to the company’s T&Cs Tinder users grant it a “worldwide, transferable, sub-licensable, royalty-free, right and license to host, store, use, copy, display, reproduce, adapt, edit, publish, modify and distribute” their content — though it’s less clear whether that would apply in this case where a third-party developer is scraping Tinder data and releasing it under a public domain license.
- facerecognizer 10y agoHe is just an amateur, I find it funny that its news since he collected only 40K pictures, any one with couple of hundred dollars and smarts can probably get few million pictures easily using pool of EC2 spot instances with disposable IP addresses. Not to mention there are several million face dataset available easily. http://megaface.cs.washington.edu http://megaface.cs.washington.edu Also there is really no point in attacking him, other than for typical clickbait outrage. Finally how is this worse than those name and shame Tinder/OKCupid/Jezebel blog posts, or the horrible actions of the Wikileaks/Intercept crooks.
- danso 10y agoMegaface is not "available easily". You have to email the team and ask for permission to get access credentials: http://megaface.cs.washington.edu/participate/challenge2.html http://megaface.cs.washington.edu/participate/challenge2.htm... Since so few details about terms of use on the dataset are available, it's reasonable to assume the access control is put up in place for reasons other than bandwidth concerns.
- JumpCrisscross 10y agoIt's disturbing that Colliani's LinkedIn lists him as a "Cybersecurity Solutions Architect" at PG&E. That's a lot of personal information for someone so clueless.
- devrandomguy 10y agoPerhaps this whole thing was just a very subtle PSA, designed to raise awareness of the dangers of using your real face as an avatar? If so, it seems to be effective, in this format.
- minimaxir 10y agoSee also: the OKCupid data incident, where a user data was scrape and released non-anonymized and OKCupid was not happy about it: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/70000-okcupid-users-just-had-their-data-published https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/70000-okcupid-use...