3 ms·
Islamic State didn't exist in 1985, and in fact few people in the west appreciated the toll Islamic theocracy took on women in the middle east. That doesn't so
by pvg 10y ago
Islamic State didn't exist in 1985, and in fact few people in the west appreciated the toll Islamic theocracy took on women in the middle east.
That doesn't sound quite right. The Iranian revolution was recent and a direct influence on Atwood's writing.
- tptacek 10y agoOh, that's a good point! Good thing Bloomberg doesn't publish my comments as columns. :) My comment could have been about 60% shorter if I just observed that, like Orwell's commentary about how the repressive undercurrents of Soviet Communism could portend things about authoritarianism in the west, The Handmaid's Tale is a pretty obvious device suggesting that the Iranian Revolution "can happen here". Which, of course, is an observation banal apparently high school kids get assigned essays on it. Go me, for not noticing.
- pvg 10y agoHaving now re-read her thing and your comment, I'm even less sure what you think is so stupid about it. She seems to be saying she thinks the 'it can happen here' interpretations are facile, that books you read as an impressionable teenager appear less revealing later in life and that she no longer listens to Suzanne Vega. These seem like fairly straightforward (banal, if you want!) observations.
- tptacek 10y agoI am having trouble today saying anything clearly or concisely. Sorry. My two points are simple: 1. The claimed timeliness of THT refers not to the prospect of American theocracy but to the currency of discussions about misogyny. 2. The dystopia imagined by THT is no less rooted in reality than 1984; in fact, THT's dystopia is more relevant today than Orwell's was or is. That's all.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- angersock 10y ago2. The dystopia imagined by THT is no less rooted in reality than 1984; in fact, THT's dystopia is more relevant today than Orwell's was or is. Given the increasingly secular nature of the US, and given that we literally have televisions (see recent revelations about IoT fuckups/overreaches) watching us and people editing mainstream history... ...yeah, sorry dude, one of these is more relevant than the other. If you want to generalize THT to be general misogyny, maybe, but if you do that then you need to treat 1984 with the same generality. EDIT: Okay HN, clearly we are living on the precipice of a collapse of western civilization into militant theocracies. Clearly this co-opting of economics and politics by religious whackos is somehow more likely than a ubiquitous surveillance state kept in perpetual war to benefit a small elite . Obviously, this is the more realistic dystopia, and my internalized bigotry is somehow preventing me from seeing the truth. Or, you know, you're wrong.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 10y agoI don't really follow any of this. THT is indisputably about misogyny (and racism, and authoritarianism). You don't have to take my word about that. And, of course, 1984 is drawn from Soviet communism, but not "about" communism.
- manicdee 10y agoUbiquitous surveillance state doesn't exclude militant theocracy. We could have both if you don't work hard enough to prevent that happening.