4 ms·
That sounds susceptible to a lot of "tragedy of the commons" problems. It's hard enough to make the top-10 nations collaborate against climate change - good luc
by xg15 10y ago
That sounds susceptible to a lot of "tragedy of the commons" problems. It's hard enough to make the top-10 nations collaborate against climate change - good luck with hundreds or thousands of small communities.
Similarly, this looks like a world in which few rights or standards could be taken for granted, because everything is decided in local committees or "multilateral" deals between some groups of communities: Whether you'll be allowed to trade with or travel into another community will depend on the specific rules and agreements your and the other community decided to take part in.
In those negotiations, communities with natural advantages will likely be able to make better deals and increase their advantage, which may lead to a growing inequality between communities.
Finally, who is going to run large-scale infrastructure like roads, water, the electric grid, the internet, etc? If history is any indication, some gib private actors or a small number of powerful communities. Other communities will have to negotiate with them to be allowed access to the infrastructure - which is great for the private actors because this means there is absolutely no one who has any leverage over them...
- wav-part 10y ago(Warning: opinions without citation) Collective will has never solved anything. As always it will be technology. Whether you'll be allowed to trade with or travel into another community will depend on the specific rules and agreements your and the other community decided to take part in. At smaller scale it will be much more obvious how important these things are. In those negotiations, communities with natural advantages will likely be able to make better deals and increase their advantage, which may lead to a growing inequality between communities. Like now ? Inequality is natural state. War against inequality is just waste of resource. If history is any indication, some gib private actors or a small number of powerful communities. Why is that a problem ? Use of force is only injustice in my book. Other than that everything is fair game. Many will be losers and few will be winners. But _everyone_ will fail most of the time. That is, there is no such thing as a private actor or community winning all of the time.
- xg15 10y ago> Collective will has never solved anything. As always it will be technology. Technology is a tool. There are always humans behind it. (If nothing else, the people designing the algorithms for the AI overlords) Technology may help us to reach our goals, but in my opinion, it's rather useless if we're not even clear what our goals are. > At smaller scale it will be much more obvious how important these things are. And then what? It's obvious today how important clean drinking water is. Still people use access to water as a bargaining power and you might not have access to it if you live in a shitty part of the world and have nothing to offer. I don't see why it would be different here. > Like now ? Inequality is natural state. War against inequality is just waste of resource. Then I honestly don't understand the logic of anarcho-capitalists. So our current system is broken because, even though it has some checks, it still leads to too much accumulation of power. Therefore we should replace it with a completely unchecked system which will lead to even more accumulation of power - but that's ok because suddenly accumulation of power is actually fine and there is absolutely nothing we could do about it anyway. How does that make any sense? > Why is that a problem ? Use of force is only injustice in my book. In mine, it isn't. But even if it were, who is keeping the communities from using force? > Other than that everything is fair game. Many will be losers and few will be winners. But _everyone_ will fail most of the time. That is, there is no such thing as a private actor or community winning all of the time. Yes, dominant powers change over time. For most of human history, that timespan was roughly "every few centuries". If you're talking about human life spans, it's absolutely possible that some groups are winning all the time and everyone else is losing all the time. (Oh, and those events where power actually shifted? They usually weren't very pleasant to live in either) The whole idea of our current system is to prevent that by imposing restrictions on power.
- wav-part 10y ago> I don't see why it would be different here. It would not. But then the water-poor would realize its better to be practicial than idiological. I believe in real life noone is all-poor. One as an individual or group has always something to offer. The water-poor/everyone would realize that there is cost of socialism which not everyone can afford. > How does that make any sense? Ancap are not happy with current state of inequality which is due to violence. Inequality due to trading-power is "ok". Though not bundled with ancapism, wars against current market leaders are heavely encouraged and just occur naturally. > If you're talking about human life spans, ... Though I concur this is not what I said. If you restrict the time period ofcourse you are going to find all sort of anomolies. > The whole idea of our current system is to prevent that by imposing restrictions on power. Current systems do not distinguish between powers who break NAP and who does not. If current systems just focus on the former and leave latter alone not only the unpleasent shifts of powers can be avoided but also libertarianism/ancapism need not exist.