4 ms·
If you read the article he linked, it seems like the author is talking about decades - he references his 25th college reunion and speaks as if it was several ye
by nostrademons 16y ago
If you read the article he linked, it seems like the author is talking about decades - he references his 25th college reunion and speaks as if it was several years ago.
His point was that because the smart guys are on Wall St, they're not actually running the businesses and institutions that Wall St is investing in. So the companies that back all these financial assets are now being run by incompetent doofuses, while the people who used to make sure everything ran smoothly are now shuffling money from one dysfunctional company to another.
There's a lot of truth to this - Warren Buffett has been saying the same thing for about 15 years. It used to be that the top grads in each class would become professors, or entrepreneurs, or public servants, and would use their intelligence to invent tangible things that make people's lives better. Now the top grads usually go into finance, and they still invent things, but the things they invent are increasingly opaque ways to slice up a declining pool of real assets.
Assuming that you're a reasonably intelligent guy, you're actually good evidence for the point the article is making. If you didn't work at a hedge fund, perhaps you'd be working for Google, or performing basic research, or founding the companies of tomorrow. He's talking entirely about opportunity cost: the opportunity cost of having the smart people in the world allocating capital is that they aren't out in the world producing capital.
- tansey 16y agoI think that's a separate argument from the one the OP is making, based on his selected quotes. I've read the article before, but I just re-read it to refresh myself. The issue I take with it is that the story pitched to the reader is: 1) Life gets expensive and Wall st. produces tons of millionaires. 2) Smart guys go to Wall St. with dreams of making enough money to become leisurely professors. 3) Extra derivatives are created by smart guys which then destroy the world. This seems ridiculous on several levels. First, virtually no one goes into massive debt by getting a PhD in the sciences; scholarships, grants, and stipends are always there to support bright students. Second, people have been doing sophisticated derivatives for a very long time; most people have no idea what an option is, much less how to price one, and that dates back to the days of Ed Thorpe. Third, I really just cannot believe that having a system where idiots manage money with the help of other idiots is less prone to disaster than idiots managing money with the help of smart guys. The one thing that the author does have right is that the financial incentives are out of whack. That comes back to the deregulation issue which I consider the cause. As for myself, I am also doing a startup and a couple research projects in my spare time, as well as going back to get my PhD starting 2011, so I guess Warren can sleep a little better knowing I'm not going to be "wasting" my life forever. ;)