3 ms·
The issue is that it's rude to quote someone and then respond with an emoji. If what they're saying is relevant then it merits a proper response. If it isn't re
by foldr 10y ago
The issue is that it's rude to quote someone and then respond with an emoji. If what they're saying is relevant then it merits a proper response. If it isn't relevant, or you don't have anything to say in response, then you shouldn't quote it in the first place.
You're welcome to come up with your own theories of what the emojis mean, but I don't see any point in doing so.
- grzm 10y agoThis is a slide deck from a presentation at Percona Live 2017. https://www.percona.com/live/17/sessions/postgresql-response-uber https://www.percona.com/live/17/sessions/postgresql-response... We're missing everything that was said by the presenter. I would strongly suspect that the presenter said something about the slide.
- foldr 10y agoYeah that's a fair point. I’d suggest that’s a reason to think carefully before posting a slide deck, though. If essential points are left off the slides entirely, then it may not be such a good idea to post the slides by themselves.
- grzm 10y agoI think many people haven't had the issues you personally do with the presentation. That said, other comments in this thread make clear that you are not the only one to have read them as snarky. It's very useful to be charitable and give people the benefit of the doubt when reading their communication. I think there's a lot of useful information in the slide deck presented in a succinct way, and publishing them as-is is a useful and efficient way to do so. I think with very little effort it's easy to interpret the shrugs as I did above, and there's little if any additional information that needs to be address along with the final shrug. I wouldn't have presented it this way, but I don't see any malevolence or negative intent on the part of the author.
- jldugger 10y agoThere's kinda two audiences for this paper: Uber, the engineering team that migrated away from psql, and the tech community at large, which saw Uber's technical decision as a signal about the quality of psql. IMO, the shrug emoji is fine. If it were the only response, that'd be a problem but the author gives a proper response in the following slide: it was a short lived bug, and it's not like MySQL is objectively better. I can think of a few MySQL problems I've run into, like fixing a data loss bug in the rollback code by refusing transactions larger than 10 percent of the rollback buffer until a real fix can be published, making backups, restores and migrations pretty much impossible. But the tl;dr here is that psql will continue to get a black eye in the tech community as long as slony exists and is useful.