2 ms·
As discussed in http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitty_Genovese#Psychological_research_prompted_by_the_murder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitty_Genovese#Psychologi
by btilly 16y ago
As discussed in http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitty_Genovese#Psychological_research_prompted_by_the_murder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kitty_Genovese#Psychological_re... the standard narrative is that the 38 neighbors were aware, and didn't do anything because everyone expected someone else to. This narrative is standard in introductory psychology books, and I've encountered it in multiple places. As soon as I began the article I knew that that was what was being referred to, and I only read on because I was curious to know more about the story.
In fact none of the neighbors were aware of the full sequence, only two were aware that stabbings happened, multiple neighbors reacted (calling police, driving the attacker away), and none were witness to the final rape and murder. This is a very different story, and completely undermines the intended point that people become less likely to act when they see others not acting.
- zackattack 16y agoI do not think the criticisms undermine the validity of "Genovese" as a good illustration of social proof; however, I agree that it was a bad example to use simply because it introduced all of this skepticism. You're right. I edited the article to remove the reference.
- btilly 16y agoI would say that Genovese was an important incident that helped develop theories about social proof. Certainly the popular presentation of the story makes a great parable about social proof. But I don't see how the actual events are evidence for social proof. Generally the neighbors either did act, or else had no reason to believe that anything more was going on than a minor drunken argument. Neither suggests that people think it is OK to not act when they see others not acting. A much better example would be something to do with crowd psychology. Like the bandwagon effect, or groupthink. (The Bay of Pigs fiasco may be a good example.)