3 ms·
The problem is, you're not telling your partner 'I would like to buy at $20'. You're telling him 'I would like to buy at $15', but as in any negotiation you ha
by SkyMarshal 16y ago
The problem is, you're not telling your partner 'I would like to buy at $20'. You're telling him 'I would like to buy at $15', but as in any negotiation you have a max price you are willing to pay and he has a minimum price he is willing to sell, but neither of you announces that to each other.
However, he basically has the ability to read your mind and see that he can negotiate you up to $20, while you lack the same ability to reciprocate.
It's an unfair advantage enabled by large firms having the money to buy better access to market mechanisms and powerful enough computers to exploit them.
- BrentRitterbeck 16y agoThis is similar to me saying that it is unfair for a 6 foot 7 inch person to play offensive tackle in the NFL when I am only 6 ft 1 inch and would like to play the NFL as well. The world is not fair. Some people will have the resources to do certain things while other people will not. EDIT: Before you go on to say that football and investing are two very different things, let me state that I am fully aware of that. I've had that conversation before when this topic comes up. Common people are able to participate in the investment process while only a very few get to play in the NFL. The people that are upset are the ones that try to game the market themselves but are under-capitalized. From prior conversations, long-term investors simply don't care about these things. The people all up in arms are the one's that have lost money because they are trying to do something they are not in a position to do. I'm only talking about trading stocks and futures here; the more advanced investment products, like CDOs and CDSs, and the issues in the news regarding them, are a totally different conversation.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoIt's not similar to that at all, or even related in any way. Without transparency and fair mechanisms, markets break down. Participants getting exploited withdraw and find other ways of getting what they need, most recently through dark pools. Crucial liquidity diminishes, and eventually all that's left are the crooks. The suckers are broke and honest non-suckers are gone. If you want functioning capital markets, you have to regulate and crack down on stuff like this.
- BrentRitterbeck 16y agoYou say that it is essential to crack down on high-frequency trading. On what grounds? The markets function because these firms provide liquidity. If you want to see what happens when these firms stop providing liquidity, you can look at the flash crash. To crack down on the industry in the ways being proposed would have the exact opposite effect that the regulators are looking for. Spreads would widen. Volatility would increase. Volume would severely drop. Congress has no idea that they are legislating the next financial crisis into existence.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoOh right, I totally forgot there was no liquidity in the markets before HFT came along. How silly of me. The flash crash was exacerbated by HFT, not caused by the absence of it. Congress doesn't have to outlaw HFT, but it does have to outlaw HFT order limit probing. Though it would probably not hurt to completely unplug HFT anyway. There is zero net benefit to the markets from it, and there will be plenty of trading and liquidity without it (just as there was before it). Arguably even more, as funds that now resort to dark pools return to the open markets. Volatility spikes would still exist (always have always will), but HFT exacerbates them, lack of HFT mitigates them. The problem with HFT is that it is not a productive enterprise. It does not take raw materials like copper and sand, and apply labor, capital, and innvotation to turn them into products worth more than the sum of their inputs, creating real wealth. It doesn't mine or farm those raw materials. It doesn't even provide a specialized service that saves people time/money. All it does is skim off the top of the global capital flow, increasing the cost of that capital to everyone else, particularly to the productive enterprises mentioned above. It is parasitic, and gives nothing back, despite the 'story' Wall Street has created to justify it.
- clammer 16y agoIs it me, or are there a lot of communist on HN? Such fear and loathing of free markets. Everyone should be equal. We should all get a 5% return. We should cease all activities deemed "non productive" by the state and get back to work in the mines.