5 ms·
Britain’s Brexit denial
- _nalply 10y agoSwiss here. It seems that there's a difference between walking out and never have joined, the latter being a lot easier. Another difference: Switzerland is part of the Schengen area, but UK is not. Have a look at the map in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area - there is no hole in central Europe where Switzerland uses to be. Schengen is only one of the many sectors where Switzerland is actively participating in EU programs. It's not easy for Switzerland. Sometimes the EU can be very rough and demanding. I wish the UK good luck and I hope that everything works out acceptably.
- Boothroid 10y agoIt's interesting - if I look at the pro-EU crowd here in the UK (people like Gina Miller, Nick Clegg and his wife) I see a mixture of ideology and careerist reasons for attaching themselves to the project, and I suspect that's the main driver in Brussels too - ambitious types that, having inserted themselves into positions where they stand to benefit, now agitate with wild-eyed zeal for ever closer union, when the benefits of this for those whose interests they claim to represent are debatable.
- Boothroid 10y agoAny attempt to harm the UK economically will, inevitably, also harm the EU as a consequence. The UK has a massive trade deficit with the EU due to its love of BMWs, prosecco, etc. etc. Who is going to pick up the slack for this lost trade? The reality of the consequences of disrupting this trade does seem to be starting to dawn on other key figures i.e. the EU trade commissioner. And if we are going to talk denial, I think you could also reasonably argue that Brussels and northern EU members have demonstrated a considerable degree of denial or worse, open contempt about the plight of the southern EU members due to the imbalances brought about by the Euro. You might also say their refusal to countenance the possibility that the UK could vote to leave the EU was verging on denial. And finally regarding Merkel's comments, perhaps worth remembering how well it ended for Germany last time they threatened Britain..
- Oletros 10y agoBut the UK can't have the cake and eat it. They want all the benefits Norway or Switzerland have without the duties those countries have
- Boothroid 10y agoWell, nor can the EU have its cake and eat it - if a workable trade agreement cannot be reached post-Brexit, both sides suffer. I hope that commerce can be put above ideology here. I'd be interested to know how those in the EU whose livelihoods depend on trade with the UK would view it - I suspect they wouldn't care greatly about a little compromise if it meant keeping their jobs. What are the supposed amazing benefits of the EU versus having work?
- Oletros 10y agoWhy should commerce be above free movement of people or other things? > 'd be interested to know how those in the EU whose livelihoods depend on trade with the UK would view it Yes, because nobody in the UK would lose the jobs and people won't suffer with higher prices. Yes, the title is apt
- Boothroid 10y agoAt the end of the day, the high-minded principles of free movement etc. matter less than having food on your plate. That's what I'm arguing. Fact is that the EU and specifically the Euro have had negative impacts for millions across the EU. Why is it that the majority of service jobs in the UK seem to be filled by Poles, Spanish, Italians, etc.? I've no problem with this btw, I'm just pointing out that it's telling that the Eurosceptic UK is still a better option than the home country for millions of EU citizens. And I'm not saying that the UK won't suffer - the point is that everyone will suffer.
- tzs 10y agoMaybe Mexico and Canada could pick up some of that slack? I was just reading an article somewhere, for example, about how Mexico has increased powdered milk imports from the EU by over 100% over the last couple of months, in order to reduce dependency on the US. The US currently export $231x10^9 worth of goods to Mexico per year, and $267x10^9 to Canada. That's a lot of potential importers in Mexico and Canada who might be nervous over trade relations with the US and open to some new sources.