5 ms·
Practical ethical behavior isn't just about decisions in the moment. It's about making good long-term decisions so you are in a position to make good short-term
by wpietri 10y ago
Practical ethical behavior isn't just about decisions in the moment. It's about making good long-term decisions so you are in a position to make good short-term decisions.
You can always create some hypothetical narrow situation that will justify a bad action. But so what? If you do the bad action, you are still morally responsible for the bad action. And you have still fucked up enough in your life that you let bad people put you in a position of having to choose between one bad action or another.
In the early days of the consumer Internet, I'd often call up spammers and talk with them. A lot of the time I heard this blame-shifting, self-justifying nonsense. They had bills to pay! Families to feed! They were just going through a bad patch! They were good people, it wasn't their fault, they had to spam!
Circa 2009 there were a lot of people who were losing their suburban homes because they took out loans to cover "bills". And in the sympathetic articles about them, you'd see the house with the picture of two nice cars and a boat and they'd be wearing nice, name-brand clothes. Ah, those bills. And sure, I get that consumer capitalism ruthlessly exploits the primate status drive. But c'mon, people: you have no good choices now because you made some pretty bad choices before. Own your shit.
You see the same exact moral vacuity in startup founders who get in over their heads. "I'm a good person! But we just had to sell your personal data to the highest bidder! But I'm a good person!" Well sure, but you also took millions of OPM to start a tech company with no clear revenue model while simultaneously telling your users that you were the most ethical company ever. Water runs downhill, genius.
TL;DR: Ethics aren't cheap. If you really want to have them, you have to prepare.
- problems 10y agoI'm not sure that's a great example, if you're in the position to sell data to the highest bidder that means people were stupid enough to give you that data and you're free to do what you like with it. Then again, maybe this is just an ethical divide.
- wpietri 10y agoIf your theory of ethics is "when people trust me I can do anything I want to them", then we are at best on opposite sides of an ethical chasm. But I'm not sure that "I will take advantage of anybody I can" qualifies as ethics at all.
- problems 10y agoIt's not really taking advantage if they gave it to you consensually. You're not taking anything from them, they're not losing anything, they gave you info voluntarily, you're just selling it.
- clay_to_n 10y agoHow would you apply that thought if a friend gave you their credit card and asked you to buy something for them? What about if you ran an online store that held credit card numbers, or any other sensitive data?
- problems 10y agoBoth situations are different - they're losing something that they didn't give you - their money.
- mercer 10y agoWhat's the difference between someone being 'stupid' enough to accidentally give you access to their money and someone being 'stupid' enough to give you their private information?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- problems 10y agoIt's not private information, it's information they gave me in exchange for a service.
- clay_to_n 10y agoI disagree - in both situations, they gave you something for one purpose, and you used it for a different purpose that they didn't consent to. They didn't give you their info so that you could sell it.