3 ms·
Regarding the Boston Tea Party, These are the folks who led the Revolution. These were not the downtrodden. These were not the oppressed. These were people who
by icebraining 10y ago
Regarding the Boston Tea Party,
These are the folks who led the Revolution. These were not the downtrodden. These were not the oppressed. These were people who stood to lose huge amounts of wealth because of the King's policies. And so they fought a Revolution. Which was, by the way, not very popular. Sixty percent of the colonists either were neutral or opposed to the Revolution.
http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2016/12/bruce_bueno_de_1.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2016/12/bruce_bueno_de_1.ht...
- dsp1234 10y agoI hope I never live in a place where only people of certain economic class are allowed, or not allowed, to fight unjust laws. I also hope I never live in a place where because the majority are neutral or opposed, that unjust laws go unquestioned.
- gled 10y agoAre there any places in the world where these two things aren't true?
- zepto 10y agoWhere are you living now? I want to move there.
- krapp 10y agoThe parent doesn't appear to be suggesting that people of a certain economic class should not be allowed to fight unjust laws. Rather they appear to be countering the popular narrative that the American revolution was necessarily populist, or popular, and by extent, that all civil disobedience is necessarily justifiable. This is an important distinction to make when one is attempting to argue from authority, and the simple list of Wikipedia pages you linked to above is a weak argument from authority. Without an accurate portrayal of what that authority was, what its goals were, and what it actually believed, one cannot make a good faith argument. One example being Benjamin Franklin's often cited quote about those who give up liberty for the sake of security deserving neither. This is often invoked as a warning about the inherent harm of trusting the state, when in fact Franklin was arguing (in a very specific context regarding taxes to fund a defense against Native American raids on the frontier) against the "security" of personal defense versus the "liberty" provided by the state. While the core argument being made in the fundamentally modern reinterpretation of Franklin's words may be legitimate, one cannot ascribe that intent to Franklin's words without engaging in revisionist history. To use the American civil rights movement as an example, both sides considered themselves just, and considered the laws they disagreed with to be unjust. It cannot be the case that any law considered unjust by any party is equal to any other in the degree of its injustice, otherwise one could argue that those who considered laws against segregation to be unjust were morally equal, and equally justified, in their opposition as those who fought for segregation's end. What one considers to be unjust, and why one opposes that injustice, should be relevant to the conversation.