3 ms·
It is true that some lawyers do bad things. But what you're ignoring is the great number of bad things that lawyers don't do because either a) they are afraid o
by wpietri 10y ago
It is true that some lawyers do bad things. But what you're ignoring is the great number of bad things that lawyers don't do because either a) they are afraid of the professional consequences, b) they can get their clients to easily back off because they say, "professional ethics!" and people know it's a real thing, or c) they get disbarred and can't act as a lawyer any more.
As an example, look at the Prenda Law guy, who was basically using his status as a lawyer to run a high-tech extortion scam. He's had his license suspended, and will surely be disbarred:
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/09/prenda-lawyer-paul-hansmeier-has-his-law-license-suspended/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2016/09/prenda-lawyer-pa...
Or look at Jack Thompson, famous hater of video games, who got disbarred for making "defamatory, false statements and attempted to humiliate, embarrass, harass or intimidate" people:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Thompson_(activist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Thompson_(activist)
And of course there are plenty of people who have been disbarred for cheating and abusing clients.
I too would like the legal ethics to be stronger on the "do no harm to society" side. But there's no denying that legal ethics have real teeth. Our industry could learn something from them.
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoSure, lawyer rules have a great deal of influence as to obligations of a contractor and the decorum they're supposed to operate with. Programmers could do better there. That's not what the post I was responding to was talking about. It was talking about "all immoral or unethical activity", and specifically about surveillance, dark patterns, data aggregation, and cyber warfare. Lawyers have signed off on all of those behaviors at their organizations (particularly the surveillance and cyber warfare ones). They've done contortions to get them "approved" in contracts. If the lawyers at those organizations okayed it, it's fascicle to pretend engineering ethics would've stopped it. Further, when talking about "all immoral or unethical activity" it's entirely germain to point out lawyers routinely engage in both without consequence. tl;dr: Lawyer rules are about professional standards, not conduct. You can represent the devil in his suit to rule the world, you just need to be polite and bill fairly.
- dpark 10y ago> But what you're ignoring is the great number of bad things that lawyers don't do because either a) they are afraid of the professional consequences, b) they can get their clients to easily back off because they say, "professional ethics!" and people know it's a real thing, or c) they get disbarred and can't act as a lawyer any more. Most lawyers don't do bad things because they're decent people. Ethics codes don't stop unethical behavior any more than laws stop crimes. There is some small percentage of the population who will shy away from a crime specifically because of the potential punishment, but most people wouldn't steal or murder regardless of the law. Ditto for lawyers.
- wpietri 10y agoNot at all. Codes of ethics are very helpful in preventing unethical behavior because they summarize a large amount of careful thought about ethics. That's one of the reasons so much of religious thought and literature, theistic and non-, is about the finer details of good behavior. Being a decent person is a good start, but that's just not enough. It's a complicated world, and the obvious thing isn't always the right thing. Especially when people are embedded in an economic system that strongly rewards behavior that could easily be ethically dubious.
- dpark 10y agoAnd unethical people tend to follow ethical guidelines? Ethical guidelines can be useful for times when the person wants to do the right thing and the area is gray (e.g. should I represent a client I believe is guilty), but people who are content with unethical behavior will not be swayed by a code they promised to follow. An imperative to honor a promise implies intrinsic ethics. Most of the actions that would actually get you disbarred are pretty flagrant.
- wpietri 10y ago> And unethical people tend to follow ethical guidelines? This is a false dichotomy. Some people are deeply unethical. Some people are deeply ethical. Most people are just getting along in their lives and can be pushed in either direction by the practical and social context. Codes of ethics are helpful for everybody except the ardently unethical.