5 ms·
It's interesting how thoroughly ingrained sexist concepts are in the language. Even a verb that's fairly active like 'resist' assumes a power relation in which
by empath75 10y ago
It's interesting how thoroughly ingrained sexist concepts are in the language. Even a verb that's fairly active like 'resist' assumes a power relation in which they are in a worse position.
I'd like to see this done by country or year or language or genre.
- oblio 10y agoHeh. You have no idea. English doesn't even have proper genders. You're on easy mode. If I say: "Your manager is good.", it's neutral. You can't figure out if I'm talking about a man or a woman without something additional. In Romanian, and I guess in most Latin languages, no such luck. Except for a handful of neologisms, everything clearly mentions the gender, for better of for worse. The direct translation in Romanian: "Managerul tău e bun" is masculine (both the noun and the adjective make that obvious). The whole neutral gender movement in English sounds kind of funny for us... we could try to do it Romanian but it would be like lobotomizing the language.
- vacri 10y agoA Bulgarian colleague of mine said that even surnames are gendered - her surname is Nakova, her father's is Nakov. It plays merry hell with admin software from anglo nations which assume surnames aren't gendered, apparently.
- viraptor 10y agoSame in Czech, which I believe still enforces the -ova ending. (Please correct me if that changed)
- phillc73 10y agoNot just Bulgarian. I know Latvian surnames have the same concept. Probably others too.
- 3131s 10y agoRussian too, I'm pretty sure from watching years of tennis. Marat Safin, for example, and his sister Dinara Safina.
- finkston 10y agoWell, we're talking about gender here, not sex, and given that there are two genders [commonly represented in literature], it stands to reason that they would have different tendencies of behavior, or else there would be no difference between the genders, and the concept would not exist.
- bbctol 10y agoRight, of course. Since we live in a universe devoid of power relationships, it stands to reason that two groups described differently are in fact different, since no one has an interest in describing people other than accurately. Like how the Jews used to be all scheming and evil, but really cleaned up their act in the past few decades.
- adsfqwop 10y agoRight, of course, since we live in an universe devoid of genetic differences, it stands to reason that two groups described differently are in fact different. Genetic differences are FACTS. If you do not account for facts, you're operating in the twilight zone.
- bbctol 10y agoHey, the Twilight Zone was always my favorite show. It's a place between mystery and imagination, a place where the laws of reality are bent, a place where people arbitrarily start thinking you said genes don't exist.
- orpheansodality 10y agoIt would indeed be hard to argue that there are not genetic differences between people of different sexes. It does not, however, follow that all perceived differences in behavior between gender groups are genetic at root. It would be rather dishonest of me to say "men in the US like trucks, therefore liking trucks is embedded in the male geneome" without considering that there could be a societal aspect to that behavior. Genetic differences may be facts, but blindly assigning genetic causation to perceived behavior without completely ruling out other possible influencing factors is just bad science.
- artursapek 10y agoIs it sexist if it's reflective of reality? Men commit more aggressive crimes than women by far.
- shouldbworking 10y agoShhhhhh! Theres no room for reality in here, were pretending that gender is a made up sociological concept
- ue_ 10y agoTo my knowledge, gender is thought of as a complex of at least two aspects: those differences between what is thought of as masculine and feminine, and the roles assigned to genders. In these cases, gender pertains to the ideas of gender identity and further gender expression. In other cases, gender is also thought of as including or being inextricably related to biological sex. Gender isn't "made up" in the same way that words aren't "made up"; it is an aspect of society, but unlike words, gender is with some relation to observable physical biological expression, usually termed as 'sex'. But the concept of gender as I have seen it used is certainly depending on society, rather than physical sex. Variations within sex (such as intersex) is another question and is unrelated to gender, as far as I know.
- tomp 10y agoThe problem with "gender" as a concept is that they hijacked existing words ("man" and "woman") that were previously used for "sex". This can be clearly seen by trying to define these words without reference to sex - you can't except by defining them recursively ("men are people who identify as men"), in which case, I think a better choice would be to invent new words for this new concept.
- ue_ 10y agoSex is to male and female as gender is to masculine and feminine.
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Red_Tarsius 10y agoOnce again, US culture cherry-picks data and declares that any statistical discrepancy is caused by oppression or sexism. Other hypotheses are taboo and dismissed. You, as well as the author, jump to the morally accepted conclusion without looking at the real world. I believe in gender equality. But it is worth thinking about other hypotheses even if you don't accept them, that is, the implications of biology in human behaviour.
- circlefavshape 10y agoPeople in literature don't have a biological sex, they only have a socially-constructed gender, and so naturally they will have the characteristics of that gender ... in fact, the sum of behaviour characteristics of the genders in our stories is the social construction of gender (I started this post off as tongue-in-cheek, but now I realise it's probably true)
- Spooky23 10y agoThat's a weird conclusion to draw. Much of this reflects reality. Murder in general is committed more by men. Most reported battery and assault (beat) is committed by men. Murder by poisoning is almost exclusively committed by women. First responders or soldiers who are "saving" people trend male, etc. When you're looking at 100k fiction works, many of them are going to be romance, mystery and other dramatic type stories that reinforce these concepts.