Here is a reply to your points: 1. Yes (to the first question). Because they operate at different layers of the internet stack. ISPs operate at lower layers of

Here is a reply to your points: 1. Yes (to the first question). Because they operate at different layers of the internet stack. ISPs operate at lower layers of the stack than the school. If you fail to see how these are incompatible, please consider the following: Should you be able to choose where your electricity goes to (phone charger, tv, fridge, etc...) ? Why shouldn't your electricity provider be allowed this freedom ? 2. No (to the first question). Cable television works (conceptually) in a fundamentally different way from the internet. The provider must define its own set of protocols with each channel/network and price accordingly. The internet is distributed and free by default, there is an agreement on a common set of protocols and content gets served through these mostly in a federated way. This is different from having to establish a contract with each studio/channel and create your own offer (which is not how the internet was designed and intended to work, please read up on the physical layer alternative implementations). Also taking your argument one notch up: different protocols usually mean that you need to consider a different approach and abstraction/standard. Do not expect good things if you treat all protocols with the same standard. 3. No. Reason: The telephone network works in a different way than the way/purpose of the internet. Public switched circuit networks like the telephone network have a inherent hierarchy that is typically not trivial to pass through hence the costs that used to associated with regional/international calls and the need to create toll free numbers for special use cases. Even though in a given time window the internet used to work on top of the telephone line its intention and design is of a higher-level, all the juicy stuff on the internet happens above the physical layer. Would you complain to your ISP if facebook was down ? I don't have patience to answer the other points mostly because i feel that you didn't spend much time working/thinking on them and that possibly you don't really want them answered and are just trying to prove some void point while trying to avoid arguments. Please read up on history and technology and then rephrase them.