4 ms·
Here is a draft of a comment I plan to submit to the FCC regarding this notice: The draft seeks comment on the analysis in Paragraph 27. This analysis purports
by pdonis 10y ago
Here is a draft of a comment I plan to submit to the FCC regarding this notice:
The draft seeks comment on the analysis in Paragraph 27. This analysis purports to show that broadband Internet service is an information service because it provides users the "capability for generating, acquiring, storing, transforming, processing, retrieving, utilizing, or making available information via telecommunications." The argument given is that broadband Internet service allows users to do all these things. However, this is not the same as providing the capability to do these things. To see why, consider that providing users Internet services over dialup phone lines also allows users to do all these things; but the phone lines themselves are telecommunications services, not information services. Why? Because providing the user dialup Internet, by itself, does not provide them the capability to do all these things. That capability is provided by the endpoints: the users' computers, and the computers hosting the Internet services that the users connect to.
Exactly the same is true of broadband Internet services provided by ISPs: by themselves, they do not provide users the capability to do all these things. They only provide connections between computers at the endpoints that provide those capabilities. It is the services provided by the Internet hosts that users connect to that are "information services". The broadband Internet services that allow users to connect to those hosts are telecommunications services, and should be regulated as such.
ISPs object to analyses like the one above because they claim that they also provide the actual information services--in other words, they also provide Internet hosts that function as email servers, web servers, etc. But it is obvious that those services are separate from the broadband connection services provided by those same ISPs, because users can make use of the latter without making use of the former at all. I am such a user: I use the broadband Internet connection provided by my ISP, but I do not use any of the information services they provide; I do not use their email, their web hosting, etc. I use other Internet hosts provided by other companies for those services. The fact that ISPs offer information services as well as telecommunications services does not make their telecommunications services into information services; an ISP's choice of business model cannot change the nature of a particular service it provides. Broadband Internet connections are obviously a telecommunications service, and should be regulated as such, regardless of what other services ISPs would like to bundle with them. The FCC should continue to regulate broadband Internet service as a telecommunications service.
- thomastjeffery 10y agoSend that to your senators and congressman too. Everyone who has a voice needs this basic understanding.
- willow9886 10y agoYes, this is spot on.
- jdormit 10y agoDo you mind if I send a copy of this to my representatives (Utah) as well?
- pdonis 10y agoI'll post an updated version in this thread. I have no problem with anyone sending it to any of their elected representatives.
- 1_2__3 10y agoI promise you - promise you - that anyone who would read that letter knows everything you're saying in it anyway.
- pdonis 10y agoUpdated comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14215198 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14215198
- DigitalJack 10y agoYour comment does not address the second clause of the sentence you quote: "...or making available information via telecommunications." Which is cited as a reason to classify it as an Information service. Your third paragraph, "ISPs object to..." claims that the telecommunications portion is separable from the services provided (such as email, etc.), and yet the document you are critiquing claims the opposite in paragraph 11. I'm trying to find the reasoning as to why they claim inseparability. It's worth reading a relevant supreme court opinion to get an understanding of the opposing viewpoint [10]. I find that paragraph 67 of the universal service report (USR) to congress from the fcc (Federal-State Joint Board on Universal Service, FCC 98-67 [20], seems to be a counterpoint to yours. Specifically, the idea of an ISP apart from the physical connection -- ISPs make use of telecommunications but are not themselves the telecommunications service. "67. With regard to the lines leased by Internet service providers to provide their own internal networks, the analysis is straightforward. We explain below that the Internet service providers leasing the lines do not provide telecommunications to their subscribers, and thus do not directly contribute to universal service mechanisms." Paragraphs 80 and 81 of the USR states "The provision of Internet access service involves data transport elements: an Internet access provider must enable the movement of information between customers' own computers and the distant computers with which those customers seek to interact. But the provision of Internet access service crucially involves information-processing elements as well; it offers end users information-service capabilities inextricably intertwined with data transport. As such, we conclude that it is appropriately classed as an "information service." In offering service to end users, however, they do more than resell those data transport services. They conjoin the data transport with data processing, information provision, and other computer-mediated offerings, thereby creating an information service." [10]https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/pdf/04-277P.ZO https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/pdf/04-277P.ZO [20]https://transition.fcc.gov/Bureaus/Common_Carrier/Reports/fcc98067.pdf https://transition.fcc.gov/Bureaus/Common_Carrier/Reports/fc...