4 ms·
20% is way too high. Even ignoring the (important!) human factors, that sort of failure rate would raise the expense tremendously all on its own. We are finally
by mikeash 10y ago
20% is way too high. Even ignoring the (important!) human factors, that sort of failure rate would raise the expense tremendously all on its own. We are finally seeing a glimpse of true reusable rockets, which are the only way to do things in space at anything like a reasonable cost. A 20% failure rate means your reusable rockets can't be reused very much.
Along similar lines, even if you ignore the fear and grief factor, a 20% fatality rate means you'll never create experienced astronauts.
I also really doubt that putting the risk that high would be particularly useful. Even the worst non-man-rated rockets out there have a failure rate of something like 10%, and those failures generally wouldn't kill the astronauts if their spacecraft had a launch escape system. The Space Shuttle's fatality rate was about 2%, and that was only because it was a vastly over-complex, fragile machine with no realistic abort modes in many phases of flight. No other spacecraft made or planned could fail in the ways the Shuttle did.
A government effort probably will be expensive, but only because they're slow to adapt. It will probably be quite some time before we see a(nother) reusable government rocket.
However, a private effort won't go anywhere, because there's no business case for a moon base, nor even a "dream big" case for an Elon Musk type figure. (Mars is a better target by nearly every measure for the second one.)
The best bet IMO would be a public-private partnership, with governments providing the basic goals and funding, and private companies providing the technology and services.
- ptero 10y agoSpace Shuttle was not a major breakthrough -- we were in space and had orbital stations for a long time by then. It was supposed to be a cheaper, more convenient way to do things that we already did. Soviet space program, Apollo program are better examples and both had ~10-20% fatality rates, at least during the initial phases (for example, Apollo 11 (successful moon landing) was 6th Apollo mission; one out of those 6 (Apollo 1) was fatal). Ancient seafarers, voyagers, explorers faced more dangers and had higher fatalities than today's office clerks. If we are to keep making new voyages we should accept that there is danger involved. If we are spending $X and could make one step with success probability .9999 or 1000 steps with success probability .8 we should seriously consider both options, not let bureaucrats reject the riskier one out of hand. My 2c.
- mikeash 10y agoApollo 1 was a ground test that was retroactively given a mission name to honor the dead. If you want to count it toward the fatality rate then the denominator needs to include all the other ground tests they did, not just the flights. A more complete view would also include Mercury and Gemini. The Soviets lost a few people in flight during the early days, but the last one was in 1971. There's no reason to think we should have a similar fatality rate in 2017, with modern materials, processes, and control systems. I agree in theory that if a 20% fatality rate were somehow required, it would be acceptable for things like this. My argument is not that it's unacceptable, but that it's so high as to be a hindrance rather than a help, and that it's far beyond what's necessary even in a "damn the torpedoes, full speed ahead" type of program. We don't need airliner-level "one in a billion" safety, but something around 1% seems highly reasonable.
- Nomentatus 10y agoOf the Gemini astronauts, I believe fully one-sixth died in training accidents, mostly flight accidents. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaceflight_non-fatal_training_accidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spaceflight_non-fatal_training...
- eru 10y agoDidn't the Space Shuttle go 1000 times (yes, thousand times, not thousand percent) over budget in terms of cost of launching 1kg of payload into space?
- mikeash 10y agoI don't think so. According to the all-knowing Wikipedia, the lowest cost estimate during development was $635/lb in modern dollars. The actual cost was something like $8,000-$20,000/lb depending on whether you're measuring marginal or total costs.
- eru 10y agoThanks for looking it up. I think Wikipedia has the variable costs? If I remember right, the article I got the shocking estimates from amortized the fixed costs of developing the space shuttle over the entire life of the program---and since they did much fewer missions than planned originally, you get the crazy overrun. Anyway, even your figures are crazy. Part of the reason SpaceX can be cheaper is not because they are smarter---but because they don't have to source parts from each and every congressional district.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> 20% is way too high. Even ignoring the (important!) human factors, that sort of failure rate would raise the expense tremendously all on its own. Historically, a 20% mortality rate is not a huge barrier. Power and Plenty discusses an episode in the early European spice trade in which somebody sent several ships to India for pepper. All but one of them were lost, giving mortality much higher than 20%, but the voyage made a hefty overall profit from the single surviving ship.
- mikeash 10y agoRockets are a lot more expensive than sailing ships, and there's no equivalent to pepper on the moon.
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> Rockets are a lot more expensive than sailing ships How did you make this comparison? Do you think the ship was more or less expensive than the lives of the men crewing it?
- mikeash 10y agoIt seems fairly obvious to me that a wooden sailing ship, even built by hand with old technology, would be far easier to construct than a moon rocket. It's hard to compare costs across such a great gulf of time, but consider for example that the Spanish Armada consisted of 130 ships, and was fielded by a country of about 8 million people at the time. If a 16th-century ship cost as much as a moon rocket today, then that would be roughly like the USA building 5,000 moon rockets. Moon rockets probably cost about $1 billion or so (Saturn V was a bit under in current dollars, SLS will be quite a bit over) so that would be about $5 trillion. Less than a decade later, Spain was able to throw another 140 ships at the English, so it wasn't a one-off thing either. And that's ignoring naval or merchant ships that didn't participate in the Armada. I'd wager the ships were much more expensive than the crew at the time. Human life was quite cheap until recently (and still is in many/most parts of the world). A couple hundred man-years of of skilled laborers versus a couple hundred random nobodies?
- boznz 10y ago20% is way too high over long term, but I suspect over short term (the first dozen missions) it will be much higher than this. Also nobody will be forced to go, I'm pretty sure astronauts are very clever people who know the big risks they are taking
- mikeash 10y ago20% over the first dozen missions would be 2-3 lost missions in that first dozen, which would be unprecedented in space flight. Your last sentence confuses me. I went out of my way not to moralize the risk, and only discuss how it would pose problems in terms of cost and creating experienced people.