9 ms·
There is one general problem I have with ebooks that limits them for me when it comes to technical books, but is generally not a problem for things like novels.
by tzs 10y ago
There is one general problem I have with ebooks that limits them for me when it comes to technical books, but is generally not a problem for things like novels.
There is also a problem specific to Amazon ebook readers that holds me back from many technical books I would otherwise buy in ebook format.
First, the general problem. Suppose I am reading a 200 page mathematics book. I'm on page 150, and to understand something I want to review some point that was covered much earlier. I can close my eyes and visualize when I read that earlier point, and I get an image of the page it was on, where it was on that page, and how far it was into the book. I can pretty quickly jump back and find it.
This is not some "photographic memory" type thing. I don't "see" the page word for word, and cannot read the page number to know where to go. But I will get that the page I'm looking for had a diagram on the bottom and was a left side page, and that what I wanted was near the middle...that kind of thing.
It is enough that when combined with the way the pages are laid out in a physical sequence to give a sense of "place" to each page and the information on it. It seems kind of like a weak form of a memory palace.
With an ebook I do not get that sense of place as I read, and so if I need to find something much earlier in the book I have to rely on the search function or the table of contents, and often have to do a lot of paging around (which is slow on eInk readers). It usually takes a lot longer than it would have taken in the paper book.
The second problem, specific to Amazon's ereaders, is very inconsistent handling of images. For example I have some chess books that make extensive use of images for chess diagrams.
On my eInk Kindles, the chess diagrams are about the size of a postage stamp.
On the Kindle application for OS X, they are about the size that they would be in the paper book (in other words, they are the right size).
On the Kindle application for Windows, they are postage stamp sized.
On the Kindle Cloud Reader, the are the right size.
On the Kindle app for iOS they are the right size.
Same problem for math books. They often use images for equations. If those get the postage stamp treatment it makes that book very hard to deal with.
For things where images aren't needed, and where I'm not going to have to do a lot of looking back, I've greatly enjoyed reading on Kindle. Harry Potter was fine, for instance, as was the complete Sherlock Holmes stories.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- terminalcommand 10y agoI think these are issues with formatting. Kindle has the ability to render any mathematical book or chess book with diagrams. One only needs to find a good epub/mobi. On the other hand reading magazines on kindle is painful, because they're meant to be viewed on a larger surface. I read technical books (programming) on my computer/ipad. If you intend to use the book as a reference, kindle is hard. The ability to go back and forth highlight take notes, remember what you thought by looking at the page these are very important. For example I cannot study efficiently without printed codexes. I tried converting the laws into org mode and they became somewhat manageable. But I still prefer printed copies.