4 ms·
From the New York Times: "Their [research] also suggests that the disadvantages that poverty imposes on children aren’t primarily about material goods. True, e
by Alex3917 16y ago
From the New York Times:
"Their [research] also suggests that the disadvantages that poverty imposes on children aren’t primarily about material goods. True, every poor child would benefit from having more books in his home and more nutritious food to eat (and money certainly makes it easier to carry out a program of concerted cultivation). But the real advantages that middle-class children gain come from more elusive processes: the language that their parents use, the attitudes toward life that they convey. However you measure child-rearing, middle class parents tend to do it differently than poor parents — and the path they follow in turn tends to give their children an array of advantages. [...] Can the culture of child-rearing be changed in poor neighborhoods, and if so, is that a project that government or community organizations have the ability, or the right, to take on?"
(If you read the whole article, they are using poor to mean low-income minority, i.e. black.)
- rubashov 16y agoThis ignores the nature over nurture reality of the situation, I'm afraid. Genes matter.
- Alex3917 16y agoNot it doesn't. The Hart & Risley study the article is addressing looked at the possible influence of genes, and found that the maximum influence they could have over verbal ability was maybe 20-30%. (I don't have the book in front of me, so I don't know the exact amount, but it was relatively small.)
- rubashov 16y agoI don't know anything about genes and "verbal ability" studies. But the cold hard fact is that IQ is highly genetically heritable and is very strongly correlated to schooling and professional outcomes. Look, we can strip babies away from their parents en masse and force them into "optimal upbringing" experiments, as perhaps you are suggesting. Or, we can celebrate diversity and acknowledge that different groups of people are going to fit into society in different ways, and it's nobody's fault.
- cia_plant 16y ago"heritable" does not mean "determined by genetics" FYI.
- rubashov 16y agoWording revised. Identical twin studies show it is determined by genetics.
- jtheory 16y agoIdentical twin studies where the twins were implanted into different women's uteruses? Because if not, you aren't proving "determined by genetics"; you're possibly just showing effects of good/bad prenatal care. So I guess I'm curious about your sources... you can find poorly-designed studies badly interpreted by news media to prove just about anything.
- scott_s 16y ago"As perhaps [he] is suggesting"? He suggested nothing of the sort. He didn't even come close to implying it. Please don't play those kinds of games here.
- rubashov 16y agoNobody is playing games and perhaps you should look up "perhaps". He presents the idea that poor people are incapable of raising their children as a useful fact. The only way this information could be useful is some sort of policy of intensive state interference in child upbringing. We've two competing hypotheses here, both unpleasant: 1) Genetics explains a lot of group differences. 2) Poor groups can't raise their own children and there should be intervention. How on earth #2 is less offensive is beyond me. Sounds a lot like the native american forced assimilation attempts to me.
- Retric 16y agoThis is not a black a white world and nothing says you need to act on information. Is also possible for poor diet to represent 25% of the problem, poor DNA to make up 25%, bad luck to hit 25% and few options to make up the last 25%. Given that breakdown there would be plenty of options outside forced adoption or sterilization. PS: Most "black" people in the US are less than 1/2 black genetically. And there are also plenty of poor white, Latino, and Asian’s.
- noarchy 16y agoWhile I don't think that this should be over-emphasized, 20-30% is greater than "zero", meaning that genes do matter, right?
- moron4hire 16y agoNo, I think they just mean poor. It absolutely applies to the poor community in my home town, which is (to put it succinctly) very "redneck".
- Alex3917 16y agoThey're not talking about people who sit around in cafes reading Finnegans Wake, they're talking about people of low socioeconomic status. This theoretically includes more than just blacks, but in practice the specific reforms they are talking about are only being applied to predominantly black innercity schools. You don't see any poverty stricken districts in Vermont or Appalachia using these methods, because they are specifically designed to 'correct' black culture. This is also what bill gates and Obama are endorsing, incidentally. Anyway if you want to learn more, go read Paul Toughs new book. (But read Punished by Rewards and Underground History of American Education first, because then you'll appreciate why it's fucked up much more.)