3 ms·
> Intelligence is information processing That's a claim. What is your support for this? Computers in the 1940s could process information. Were they intelligent
by goatlover 10y ago
> Intelligence is information processing
That's a claim. What is your support for this? Computers in the 1940s could process information. Were they intelligent?
> just means better information processing: higher rate, volume, and quality of input and output.
Computers have been able to perform information processing better than humans from the beginning, thus the reason for their creation. Information processors are tools to extend human intelligence.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoI think that there's an additional problem with that claim: the converse may be false. Even if "intelligence is information processing", that does not mean that "information processing is intelligence". This is, I think, what you were trying to say with your point about computers in the 1940s. Sure, they could add really fast. Did that make them intelligent? Or is intelligence, even if it is information processing, is it a specific kind of information processing? If so, do we even know what kind of information processing it is? I am inclined to say no, we don't. But then, I'm not sure that I buy that intelligence is (just) information processing, either.
- rojobuffalo 10y agoThe exact quote is "Intelligence is a product of information processing in physical systems." It's the scientific definition rather than the colloquial definition.
- goatlover 10y agoThat's a philosophical assumption of what intelligence is. It's based on the metaphor that thought is calculation, and computers are thinking by virtue of manipulating symbols, and human brains are therefore doing the same thing in wetware.
- rojobuffalo 10y agoThere isn't any counter evidence at this point that it's a false premise.