5 ms·
To be fair, xoa and Ken are typically talking about Federal agents, not the cops from your local police department.
by pavel_lishin 10y ago
To be fair, xoa and Ken are typically talking about Federal agents, not the cops from your local police department.
- tptacek 10y agoKen White would say the exact same thing about talking to the police. I think there's an unspoken subtext to this, which is especially painful on nerd message boards where we contest the existence of unspoken subtext, that you'll still help the police do their job when it makes sense to do so.
- lj3 10y ago> I think there's an unspoken subtext to this That's very much a mindset from your generation. It's not at all prevalent in the newer (millennial and younger) generations. We grew up with more real world tales of people being screwed over by overzealous police than real world tales of murder, muggings and drug crime. We're more likely to give the benefit of the doubt to anybody suspected by the cops than we are to give the benefit of the doubt to the cops themselves.
- derefr 10y agoEh, I don't know. Have you lived in a ghetto†? (Not a racial ghetto; I mean a class ghetto—the part of a city usually referred to as "the projects.") In a ghetto, "murder, muggings and drug crime" are [still] facts of life. In a ghetto, police cars are like beacons radiating "no crazies are gonna try to get in your face" as long as you stay within line-of-sight of one. Homeless people cluster near police stations in ghettos—for protection. In a ghetto, someone's always passed out on a street corner, and the police are always there trying to see if they're just drunk or if they need to get to the hospital. Once or twice a night (more often on Fridays), you'll see a dude being forced into a cop car while a working girl stands there crying and bruised. If you live in a ghetto, you've probably been mugged yourself. In fact, it's probably happened more than once. (3 times for me!) As well, you've probably been "threatened"—ended up surrounded by some "friendly" strangers, in situations that could very well have resulted in your death, if you did anything to provoke anyone. You've also probably had people follow you for blocks ranting and trying to grab at you. Or follow you, giving you a "guided tour" you didn't ask for, then insisting you pay them for their "tour" to get them to go away. And each time one of these things has happened, you've likely wished that there was a police officer nearby, but there wasn't; they were too busy dealing with all that other shit above. If you live somewhere "nice", police officers can seem kind of pointless, and might in fact be a bit stir-crazy and awful. But if you live in a place where they're as over-worked as hospital ER staff with all the shit that goes on each day, you're usually somewhat thankful to have them there. Even if you still do feel intimidated and a bit scared every time you pass by one. --- † To disclaim in advance: I don't mean one of those weird mid-US ghettos, with the police who grew up somewhere else, likely of a different race from the people who live there; the kind where all the awful racial police violence happens. I mean a ghetto patrolled by its own.
- lj3 10y agoDo the majority of the generations I mentioned come from ghettos? I'm not arguing against the efficacy of the police or whether or not we need them. I'm describing a mindset prevalent among a large number of people. I'm aware exceptions exist.
- derefr 10y agoYes and no; the majority of young people living on their own in large cities at this point are living in half-gentrified previously-class-ghetto areas, still home to many social-housing buildings, and still with high crime rates. Because these are the "affordable" places to live in a city. I don't know what percentage of the generations you mention qualify as "young people living on their own in large cities", but I think it's a fair amount. Enough to skew the results against a supermajority having your described viewpoint.
- pm24601 10y ago> you'll still help the police do their job when it makes sense to do so. I bet a black or hispanic man would have a completely different perspective. Hopefully, one will comment.
- derefr 10y agoI bet someone who lives outside the US (say, a British person, or someone from Kenya) would also have a completely different perspective. I would invite those, too, but their perspectives might make the commenters here extremely confused, if they didn't mention they were talking about non-American police.
- tptacek 10y agoI live on a majority black block and have watched my neighbors help the police. The notion that black and latino people automatically oppose law enforcement is also troubling. Like (I presume?) most black people, I believe policing is structurally racist. But then, so too is exposure to crime, which disproportionately impacts poorer minority neighborhoods. The notion that black people and the police are natural adversaries doubly victimizes poor black people: first by ratifying the hostility they (definitely) experience from police officers, and second by putting them out of the protection of the law itself. It's an easy way to try to score points on a nerd message board, amongst an audience of people who are extremely unlikely to experience violent crime. It's also callously instrumentalist. Find a better way to make this point, is what I'm suggesting.
- dragonwriter 10y agoNo, the advice, insofar as it applies, applies to all law enforcement; the narrow exceptions may be more likely with local LE thna federal agents, but the general principle is the same, as are the considerations that go into deciding whether an exigency that creates an exception applies (including that you must apply extreme distrust to any statement by the LE agent, local or not, that seems to suggest such an exigency since they can and will lie to get you to believe such a situation exists.)