4 ms·
If I'm reading this right, I could make a partnership (LLC or S-corp) and use it for normal activities, investment, consulting, etc., and I'd pay 15% total. Th
by amluto 10y ago
If I'm reading this right, I could make a partnership (LLC or S-corp) and use it for normal activities, investment, consulting, etc., and I'd pay 15% total. This is nuts. Heck, Uber and Lyft drivers could set up as passthroughs and save a bunch. This is nuts.
For the record: I think slashing the corporate rate is a good idea, but only if long-term capital gains are taxed high enough that the overall rate is reasonable.
- joshuaheard 10y agoThe LLC would pay 15%, but then you would pay your normal individual rate on top of that: 10%, 25%, or 35%. If you selected the LLC as a pass through entity, you could avoid the 15% tax on the LLC, and would pay your regular individual rate.
- amluto 10y agoThat would be a tax increase (currently the LLC pays nothing), and I don't think it's what's proposed. From the article: > Beyond cutting the tax rate to 15 percent for large corporations, which now pay a rate of 35 percent, Mr. Trump also wants that rate for a broad range of firms known as pass-through entities — including hedge funds, real estate concerns like Mr. Trump’s and large partnerships — that currently pay taxes at individual rates, which top off at 39.6 percent. I think Trump really is suggesting that, when you have income reported on Schedule K-1, you would pay 15% tax on that income.
- joshuaheard 10y agoAs I stated, there are two ways to tax an LLC: as a corporation (with a a separate proposed tax rate of 15%), and as a partnership (pass-through to taxpayer, no separate tax, taxpayer pays at individual rate). I posted the text of the plan, and there is no pass-through limit of 15%. There are no pass-through limits in the current law. If there was a 15% pass-through tax limit, it would be absurd, because everyone in the 25% and 35% tax brackets would just form LLCs and get paid through that. The Times is misconstruing the plan in order to give an absurd result, which they have done in the past with Trump.
- danielvf 10y agoNo, that's not how taxes work in the US. Business taxes are before, and in addition to your income tax. Single member LLCs get special treatment - you only pay personal income taxes and self employment taxes, but not business income taxes. But let's talk about business income tax. Let's say you have a company that you own but do not work for (so I can skip payroll taxes). The company does $2,000,000 in sales at a cost of $1,700,000. The company has a profit of $300,000, which it currently pays corporate taxes of $120,000 on. After corporate taxes, you take home $180,000 in personal income. Then you pay personal income taxes of about $62,000 if you live in CA. You end up with $118,000 out of the original $300,000 profit. This double taxation is a reason many people support ditching seperate corporate taxes altogether or at least lowering it substantially.
- amluto 10y ago> No, that's not how taxes work in the US. Business taxes are before, and in addition to your income tax. Businesses are either taxed as corporations (so they pay their own taxes and owners treat them as capital assets) or as partnerships (so their taxes are rolled into their owners' taxes but owners can distribute assets tax free). Trump is talking about changing the tax code, and partnerships don't currently have a tax rate, since they don't pay the corporate tax. It sounds to me like his proposal is to lower the rate paid by their owners. > Single member LLCs get special treatment - you only pay personal income taxes and self employment taxes, but not business income taxes. Multi-member partnerships, too. AFAIK the only thing that's special about single-member partnerships is that they don't file separately. This has no major effect on taxes paid.
- danielvf 10y agoWhat the White House memo actually said was "15% business tax rate". I don't see anything in what the White House actually said about replacing personal taxes with business taxes.