5 ms·
Given 1. a site that appears to have been used by humans to do some kind of processing of bones, and 2. very old (130k) bones at that site that have been proc
by tzs 10y ago
Given
1. a site that appears to have been used by humans to do some kind of processing of bones, and
2. very old (130k) bones at that site that have been processed,
how would you rule out the possibility that the site was made and the bones processed by people that came much later (say, 15k years ago) who found a bunch of 115k year old bones from animals that died from natural deaths and used them?
- russdill 10y agoProbably by the way they are broken.
- cityhall 10y agoDo bones maintain whatever properties they're exploiting thousands of years after the animal's death? I'd expect they'd have different wear or fracture patterns if they were very old when worked. You'd also expect a mixture of ages in close proximity. Even if all the bones being processed were old at the time, they presumably would have a mixture of 100kya, 50 kya, etc. bones jumbled together.
- ska 10y agohow would you rule out the possibility You know what? I have no idea. I have a pretty strong prior that any archeologist could tell you though. I suppose it won't surprise me if one or two pop up here to tell you, but have to imagine there are more efficient ways to find out.
- astine 10y agoI'm pretty sure that they would have been fossilized by that point. Broken rock is different than broken bone.
- simonh 10y agoFossilisation takes much longer and very different conditions over millions of years.
- ar-jan 10y agoThey say the technique used on the bones was for extracting marrow. I don't know if there could be any reason to break bones already more than 100k years old, but it seems unlikely?
- icc97 10y agoAccording to the video in the middle of that story, they were found in a silt layer which would have been buried 15k years ago [0] [0]: https://youtu.be/HyfSsgCrjb0?t=1m21s https://youtu.be/HyfSsgCrjb0?t=1m21s
- roywiggins 10y agoAt a guess, where the bones are in the ground. If they're in a layer that is 100k years old, unless there's evidence of disturbance, there's a decent argument that they were left that way at that time.
- anigbrowl 10y agofound a bunch of 115k year old bones from animals that died from natural deaths I can think of things that might kill a whole herd of animals at once, but I'm having trouble picturing their bones just lying there intact for 100,000 years before people came along.
- restalis 10y agoSeemingly not applicable in this case, but bones can stay intact for thousands of years in caves, without being buried under layers of sediments. People may later find them and find them useful to whatever purpose. (Then later another bunch of humans may find everything again and draw whatever conclusions!)
- taejo 10y agoA colleague of one of the authors of this paper commented on this point on Reddit. Old bone fractures differently from recently-living bone.
- tzs 10y agoFound an answer to this in the Reddit discussion [1] on /r/science. Fresh bone breaks in a different pattern than old bone. The breaks on the bones at this site are the kind that indicate the bone was fresh when it broke. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/67qs7r/paleontologists_have_dug_up_a_130000yearold/dgsm4vp/ https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/67qs7r/paleontolog...
- colomon 10y ago"The bone fragments, some from a mastodon’s stout thigh, were scarred with marks and notches that are hallmarks of a violent blow on fresh bone. Old bone, the scientists say, shows different fracture patterns." [1] https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2017/04/26/humans-americas-discovery-mastodon-bones/100924148/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2017/04/26/humans...