3 ms·
I can't tell if the 15% applies to LLCs. Anyone know? Is it worth becoming an s corp otherwise? Would you still have the self employment tax?
by mrfusion 10y ago
I can't tell if the 15% applies to LLCs. Anyone know? Is it worth becoming an s corp otherwise?
Would you still have the self employment tax?
- chriogenix 10y agoLLCs are passthrough entities so you pay what your personal rate. You still pay self employment tax however this might spur some to change their structure to benefit from new tax proposal Edit: there is also a proposal to change how partnerships and pass through entities are to be taxed.
- iamacynic 10y ago> LLCs are passthrough entities they can be, but a lot aren't.
- chriogenix 10y agoThey can elect to be taxed as a c Corp but I would think the vast majority are taxed as a corps or as partnerships.
- pravda 10y agoSelf employment tax = Social security tax. And I don't think it is going away. It's a regressive tax, the most beloved tax.
- dzlobin 10y agoThe proposal seems to state that pass-through entities will be subject to the 15% tax rate as well. From what I've read so far that would seem to mean that all business income from one's LLC would be taxed at 15%, and there wouldn't be any personal income tax to pay on top of that.
- tptacek 10y agoThat seems improbable, because LLC owners usually recognize all of their income as pass-through distributions; this would be akin to a capped 15% tax on all wealthy people. The reason you can propose drastically cutting the corporate tax is that it's a tax on money that is again taxed as income when it reaches households. The whole point of an LLC is not to do that. LLCs that retain lots of income in the corporation indefinitely can elect corporate taxation, to which the proposed reduced rate would presumably apply. But when the LLC distributes that money back to its members, it is again taxed as income. In any case, that may be the basis for this proposal applying to LLCs.
- dzlobin 10y ago100% agreed, which is why I was pretty surprised to read that in the article but we'll see if that's actually the intended understanding of this proposal. For reference, here is the excerpt: "Beyond cutting the tax rate to 15 percent for large corporations, which now pay a rate of 35 percent, Mr. Trump also wants that rate for a broad range of firms known as pass-through entities — including hedge funds, real estate concerns like Mr. Trump’s and large partnerships — that currently pay taxes at individual rates, which top off at 39.6 percent." Their specific mention of pass-through entities might mean that literally but it might have just been a more succinct way to group LLCs, LPs, and PLLPs.
- joshuaheard 10y agoI don't know where the NY Times gets that. It's not mentioned in the actual text of Trump's plan: http://www.marketwatch.com/story/full-text-of-trump-administration-tax-reform-principles-2017-04-26 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/full-text-of-trump-administ...
- tptacek 10y agoThat's the précis the White House gave to journalists. The WSJ covered this in more detail. Either way: don't hold your breath for an (absurd!) 15% cap on people who make money through LLCs.
- tmaly 10y agoThis would be great. When I was doing small side consulting work outside my day job, I would have to pay 1/3 of my net revenue in taxes. I always thought that was very steep if you only making a few thousand on the side.
- tptacek 10y agoNeither LLCs nor S-Corps pay corporate taxes.
- eyeinthepyramid 10y agothis tax proposal would change that though, right? it sounds like you'd now pay your personal tax rate or 15%, whichever is lower, on income received from the passthrough entity. Edit: "Beyond cutting the tax rate to 15 percent for large corporations, which now pay a rate of 35 percent, Mr. Trump also wants that rate for a broad range of firms known as pass-through entities — including hedge funds, real estate concerns like Mr. Trump’s and large partnerships — that currently pay taxes at individual rates, which top off at 39.6 percent."
- danielvf 10y agoThe official memo only mentions reducing the business tax to 15%. This would not benefit you in pass through LLC. Business taxes are on top of personal taxes, not in place off.