11 ms·
The problem with that argument is that you can use it to attack, well, anything, so long as the countervailing viewpoint is threatening to your own worldview. O
by jcranmer 10y ago
The problem with that argument is that you can use it to attack, well, anything, so long as the countervailing viewpoint is threatening to your own worldview. One could very well have applied the same objection to the null result of the Michelson-Morely experiment: since it showed that the Earth was acting weirdly with respect to the lumeniferous aether, obviously there must be something more pedestrian at work than "the aether doesn't work like we thought it did."
In Diamond's case, he's dismissing all claims of pre-Clovis settlement of the Americas. For most mainstream anthropologists, the case is settled: Clovis was not the first group of humans to settle the Americas, and the Americas were settled perhaps ~20kya, not ~13kya, probably via coastal migrations (whose sites are now underwater) rather than via the interior route blocked by the Laurentide. The biggest problem with the traditional Clovis + ice-free corridor hypothesis is that the Laurentide opened up about a 1000 years too late.
For someone like Jared Diamond, I suspect the main resistance to accepting earlier habitation of the Americas is that it throws major wrenches into the hypothesis that the mastodons were hunted to extinction by early humans.
- Will_Parker 10y ago> it throws major wrenches into the hypothesis that the mastodons were hunted to extinction by early humans. Why would some small settlements ~20kya be a problem for this hypothesis? Regardless of whether previous settlements at a smaller scale existed, the Clovis people were the first to have the technology and culture to be able to rapidly explode across the continent, and the time they did this coincides with the time of extinction pretty well, doesn't it?
- jcranmer 10y agoOne of the pieces of evidence that proponents of human overhunting of megafauna point to is the seeming correlation between "arrival of humans" and "extinction of megafauna" on most continents. Drawing that out by a few thousand years on one continent in particular weakens the correlation dramatically.
- Will_Parker 10y agoHow could some human settlements exclusively on and around the Pacific shore kill all megafauna on a whole continent? Postulating that the first settlement is more important than the time of a population explosion seems to lack the kind of common sense that Jared Diamond is talking about, to me.
- jcranmer 10y agoExcept the pre-Clovis sites aren't limited to the Pacific shore. Buttermilk Creek (15kya) is in Texas, for example.
- flukus 10y agoOr maybe there was an event that led us to over hunting. We could have been fine for thousands of years until another food supply was exhausted and what had to hunt mega-fauna more. They weren't stupid, they didn't hunt large animals unless they had too.
- btilly 10y agoDo you have a reference supporting "For most mainstream anthropologists"? Do you have an explanation for why pre-Clovis humans didn't leave a ton of remains everywhere?
- jcranmer 10y agoNo, I don't have a specific reference supporting "for most mainstream anthropologists." Rather, this comes from most of my reading of books, websites, and various forums, and the general consensus I've gotten from it all is that there's few people trying to defined Clovis-First. See <https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/3kmwfq/clovis_culture_and_the_first_people_in_america/cuysjut/?context=3> https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/3kmwfq/clovi... for an example of such a commentary.
- mturmon 10y agoThe story appears to be complicated, and there is some disagreement about basic points. The introduction to this article has a good recent summary: http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/4/e1501385.full http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/4/e1501385.full