5 ms·
Except it's credit, not their own money, so your naiive "how people spend their money has no consequences" attitude, doesn't hold water. That's the whole point.
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
Except it's credit, not their own money, so your naiive "how people spend their money has no consequences" attitude, doesn't hold water. That's the whole point.
- replies_to_all 10y agoIt is a "credit" but with margin trading one can not fall below their inital investment, so no debt can be incurred, so it still is, "how people spend their money has no consequences [to others]. A user could just as easily lose all their money betting on penny stocks with no leverage.
- lend000 10y ago> so your naiive "how people spend their money has no consequences" attitude Who said it has no consequences? People make bad decisions with money their all the time. In fact, many of the working class get their fix in real casinos, where there's no real chance of winning, even if you know what you're doing. But the parent argument is going in the direction of "people shouldn't have the freedom to use this type of product." Instead of allowing normal people (some of whom know what they are doing) to freely engage in leveraged -- or just free -- trading, would you rather people with small portfolios get their already modest earning potential chewed away by large trading fees that make short term investing impractical? The difference is that I don't think we should be protecting people from themselves.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoBut the parent argument is going in the direction of "people shouldn't have the freedom to use this type of product." No, my comment was in the direction of: "It's bad if your core business is getting unsophisticated people making trades (bets) with credit." It's the same reason we all know it's a bad idea to give someone a 400k mortgage on an ARM when we don't know if they can pay it back or not. Great way to find yourself in a recession.
- lend000 10y ago> It's bad if your core business is getting unsophisticated people making trades (bets) with credit I would agree, if there were evidence to support that primarily unsophisticated people are buying premium. However, I doubt this is the case (I'm sure someone will put together numbers on this eventually). I'm a competent trader who avoids leverage, simply because I don't want to pay for a membership (it's not just a loan; you need a gold membership, too, which is an added barrier to entry).
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoWhich is exactly my point. Based on what the stated publicly, it's in Robinhood's interest as a company to push everyone into Margin deals. Their core stated benefit of using Robinhood over other brokers is opening trading up to everyone, through ease and low carry to make it easy. Ipso Facto that means their goal will be pushing new unsophisticated traders into leveraged deals. That is 100% implicit in this whole thing. I'm not arguing that there is evidence that "primarily unsophisticated people are buying premium." I'm arguing that this is their plan going forward and it could be really really harmful to markets if they get to the scale they want to. Best case, Robinhood can cover every margin call themselves, in which case they are effectively doing what Uber does which is unsustainably subsidizing investing on credit. Worst case, they can't cover margin calls and neither can their users and they roll up. I'm just waiting for them to allow leveraged shorts...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jbooth 10y agoIf you gave me a choice between running $1k through a blackjack table, or backing $1k of an unsecured loan for margin trading by a random Robinhood user, I might go for the blackjack.
- ThrustVectoring 10y agoThe loan is secured by the assets purchased, it's not unsecured.
- jbooth 10y agoThey're offering 2x margin, if I read the article correctly. So it's at best 1/3 secured, and probably a lot less than that if you need to make a margin call and try to collect. The gigantic risk to Robin Hood isn't that they'll have problems collecting occasionally. They can make up for that by fiddling with their fees to come ahead in the average case. It's that some big market move busts everyone at once and they go bankrupt overnight.
- wfunction 10y agoQuestion: if they do go bankrupt then you still own your stocks, right? Do customers lose anything?
- omarchowdhury 10y agoRobinhood Financial is a member of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC), which protects securities customers of its members up to $500,000 (including $250,000 for claims for cash).
- wfunction 10y agoThanks!
- sobani 10y ago
- theseatoms 10y agoSure. It's Robinhood's money, which they're choosing to lend to their customers. So Robinhood can bear the consequences if the loan can't be repaid. (As others have pointed out, they have ways to protect themselves. Margin calls, forced liquidations, etc)
- rtx 10y agoAnother more clever way is to deliver shares from their own pool.
- smaddox 10y agoIs it Robinhood's money? Are they required to maintain reserves to cover 100% of the loans they issue? If not, then it's not their money.
- theseatoms 10y agoGood point. I sure hope that they're required to hold 100% reserves on loans. I'd like to see an end to fractional reserve banking. That's not unique to Robinhood, but part of a much larger conversation—one that more people should be having.