5 ms·
A great many thinkpieces will be written about this, but let me beat someone to the punch: Foucault's Panopticism is the obvious tie-in. Usually when we talk a
by hasbroslasher 9y ago
A great many thinkpieces will be written about this, but let me beat someone to the punch:
Foucault's Panopticism is the obvious tie-in. Usually when we talk about the Panopticon in the modern era, we're talking about mass surveillance or the performative act of social media. When we act in a certain (digital) way, posting this link, for example, we signal our values to the community. "You shall be known by your works". However, this kind of technology makes for an even more interesting and more troubling application of the Panopticon.
Foucault says that the group eventually becomes its own control system without the need for the central observers, that we are all at the center of our own panopticons. We watch others unfailingly, assessing their actions and putting them back in line when they stray. As we are socialized, we become more entrenched in our system of values: wear makeup, don't get fat, don't smell like cigs, don't wear stripes and plaid, and for god's sake: don't look like you're trying to hard to conform to all of this. We are both observer and observed, traversing endless nets of social expectations.
Now, instead of your peer group enforcing social expectations, we have got machines in on it! The result is something blatantly dystopian - a system that will correct you in your home before you dare venture out looking like that and embarrass yourself in front of the others. As it learns, it will learn even more that we value large breasts (but also modesty), pale skin, sleek clothes on slim waists, bodies with bulbous lips and thighs and pastel face paints. It will advise those without a perfect body to get one, and it sure as hell will provide the means by which to do so: consumption. New makeup, new tights, new corsets that you can clamp so tight it'll squeeze you into a form the camera will approve, new ways to take selfies every day to show your followers that you care enough to buy this piece of surveillance equipment so that you can "look good" without those pricey fashion magazines and stupid blogs!
- Danihan 9y agoCareful, you sound pretty individualist with all this "anti-groupthink" talk. You might lose your SV credibility.
- hasbroslasher 9y agoSV?
- Danihan 9y agoSilicon Valley.
- creaghpatr 9y agoBlack Mirror "Nosedive" anyone? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nosedive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nosedive
- cyphunk 9y agothere is a place to argue that when machines enforce social expectations over fleshy peers the panopticon analogy no longer applies, or has to move to other domains. When there is not an invisible human or culture on the other end of your panopticonic cell, the peering machine eyes that give you fashion/social/love/life advice have the same affect on the newly adapted society as the walls themselves had on the society before it. And the level of harm (implied by "dystopian" label) is debatable. I would argue that the human condition and its cultures will continue to exist largerly as usual so long as we are able retain 1 secret. With each new technological shift the unadapted generation thinks the last secret has been lost and dystopia has finally arrived. So its worth taking predictions from techo doom with a grain of salt. Regardless, this product is absurd, niche, insecure and as a result will probably have little sway. Amazon would literlly have to give it away for free and subsidise the cost on some uber (pun intended) hope of monopolising and destroying the entire brick-and-mortor fashion store industry to have any hope of significant impact, imho.