2 ms·
No, it probably couldn't; the entire premise of what they are doing is bad tech journalism. Comparing something that doesn't have any concrete data to a recentl
by KirinDave 16y ago
No, it probably couldn't; the entire premise of what they are doing is bad tech journalism. Comparing something that doesn't have any concrete data to a recently released phone, declare half the things subjective, and then draw conclusions.
The only thing they could have done to improve it without takedown is put a big disclaimer at the top, “Journalism is hard. Sorry about the pile of poop below. We dropped the ball on this one.”
- rbanffy 16y ago> The only thing they could have done to improve it without takedown is put a big disclaimer at the top, “Journalism is hard. Sorry about the pile of poop below. We dropped the ball on this one.” That would be a perfectly acceptable solution ;-) A disclaimer stating all data on the iPhone 4 is from spec-sheets would do too. It would not be hard to make a comparison matrix between the two phones from the data that's publicly available. With the proper disclaimer, it wouldn't even be a bad article - just a very preliminary one. You don't need to refrain from reporting on an important development (Apple announcing a phone is important) when you have incomplete data - all you need is to clearly state that.