3 ms·
I experience something akin to this at work all the time. There's the real-world pragmatists and the software purity philosophers. Tell the family of someone
by Waterluvian 10y ago
I experience something akin to this at work all the time. There's the real-world pragmatists and the software purity philosophers.
Tell the family of someone killed that, "____ shouldn't have purchased a device without knowing how to secure it!"
- brazzledazzle 10y agoAllowing a medical device that can kill or harm someone to be connected to the internet would be a dramatic failure of both the company that produced it and the government. Monitoring is one thing but it better be a one way street or air gapped. No one should be able to do anything to a medical device over the internet besides read information. Or even over a LAN. Even if it is much less convenient or practical.
- jessaustin 10y agoOne could make that argument in a hospital environment, but eventually patients go home. While they're at home, some telemedicine might save their lives. Should we expect e.g. pacemaker patients to know how to set up a VPN? Or maybe you're just saying that pacemakers must be controlled through direct contact only... that's on the device designers then, not on local network admins.
- brazzledazzle 10y agoYes, it should be direct contact. Even short range wireless would make me nervous without guarantees that it was just one way monitoring. I wouldn't blame network administrators for the safety of a device that should have never been on it in the first place.
- notatoad 10y agoIf you want to tug on heartstrings with the "what about medical devices" argument, it's probably just as likely that a mirai botnet will impact a life support or public safety network than that brickerbot will.
- tsuraan 10y agoTell the family that the device was defective, and the manufacturer is entirely to blame. It's the simple truth, no need to try to blame the deceased.