3 ms·
(Thinking about the far future, here.) Inertial fusion using Deuterum and Helium 3 would solve a lot of these problems. Of course, He3 is rare here on Earth. I
by Robotbeat 10y ago
(Thinking about the far future, here.)
Inertial fusion using Deuterum and Helium 3 would solve a lot of these problems. Of course, He3 is rare here on Earth.
I don't think mining the Moon for He3 makes much sense. It's just too rare in the lunar soil.
Instead, my favorite concept is mining it from Uranus (whose gravity at Earth-like pressures is actually slightly less than 1g...). There's vast amounts available at useful concentrations (in addition to deuterium). You'd need a reusable two-stage nuclear thermal rocket to get it back to orbit, but luckily there's lots of hydrogen for propellant in the atmosphere (unlike Earth where that hydrogen must be chemically split from water or methane) and we've built and tested nuclear thermal rockets before (with more recent NTR designs achieving sufficient performance for such a vehicle to close). I'm not a fan of NTR for Earth launch (a lot of cost, plus it actually requires a lot more energy since all the propellant is hydrogen, instead of a mix of methane and mostly oxygen), but it would be enabling for Uranus launch.
Here's a concept for mining Helium 3 in Uranus using floating hot-air balloon mining facilities: https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/docs/5.6_Reinert.pdf https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/docs/5.6_Reinert.pdf
- DennisP 10y agoAnother option is to simply breed He3 with pure deuterium fusion; the output of the D-D reaction is He3 half the time, and otherwise tritium, which decays into He3 with a 12-year half-life. D-D produces neutrons but at normal fission energies, not the really high energy of D-T neutrons. Fusion startup Helion, which is funded by YCombinator, is attempting a hybrid D-D/D-He3 reactor, saying the combined reaction would produce only 6% of its energy in the form of neutron radiation.
- dkirtley 10y ago6% is about the best we can do with a closed cycle. Extra-terrestrial sources could push those numbers even lower by running up to a pure D-He3 reaction.
- DennisP 10y agoYep. I think 6% is pretty good...it's enough so you don't need a heat cycle to extract electricity, and dealing with the neutron damage is easier than going to Uranus. But working fusion reactors probably also means working fusion rockets, and if we find ourselves going to Uranus anyway, all the better. If we get really good at fusion we could also use boron fusion. It uses the most common isotope of boron, which is plentiful on Earth, plus regular hydrogen, and the main reaction is aneutronic. There'd be some minor side reactions but it'd be under 1% of energy as neutron radiation, probably better than you'd get with deuterium in the mix.