4 ms·
Considering that you bring up the 'rough sex' twice, and in a way that makes it seem like the books are full of it and that sex forms a fundamental part of the
by roel_v 16y ago
Considering that you bring up the 'rough sex' twice, and in a way that makes it seem like the books are full of it and that sex forms a fundamental part of the stories and philosophy, I wonder what it is that makes this single one-page scene in one book the center piece of many reflections on her books on general. If it weren't for that one movie (was it "Cruel Intentions"?) I would've mostly forgotten about that passage. This may be because what is considered "highbrow literature" in my mother tongue (Dutch) contains (relative to English-language literature) a lot more sex, and in much more explicit and colorful ways (e.g. Jan Wolkers but also work by Belgians like Jef Geeraerts), and that reading works like these since early adolescence has blunted my sensitivity to this topic; but still - even when I try to abstract from that personal frame of reference, I find it hard to assign to them the weight that is often done (and that you are implying)
On top of that, I resent your attempt at an ad hominem by suggesting that the main audience is sexually hypertensive adolescents. Which is a shame because the rest of your post is sound (even if I don't agree with all of it), and the sophism detracts from that.
- hugh3 16y agoIt's not so much the sex, it's more the (pretty much) rape. Sure, there's only one rape scene in the books. There's also only one 90-page speech, and only one scene where the death of everybody on board a train is justified because they all just happened to have one silly political view or another. That doesn't stop these three things being at the top of my "things that annoyed me about Ayn Rand" list. This is a shame as I agree with her on many points. I'd rather people were reading Hayek than Rand, though, he's temperamentally more sensible and less... nutty.
- dantheman 16y agoFWIW the death of the people on the train is in no way justified. It is a tragedy. However, everyone on that train was in some part responsible for the disaster due not only their political views but their actual actions.
- hugh3 16y agoI'm sure this debate has been had elsewhere at some point in the past, and I don't have the book here anyway. Whether or not the text actually callously celebrates the death of all these folks, it's still a scene which kinda creeped me out, and I'm sure a lot of other people too.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- philwelch 16y ago"I wonder what it is that makes this single one-page scene in one book the center piece of many reflections on her books on general." Aside from the ambiguous rape scene in Fountainhead, there are a couple of fairly aggressive sex scenes in Atlas Shrugged as well. I mentioned it twice among several paragraphs of serious philosophical criticism, but color of the bikeshed and all that. "On top of that, I resent your attempt at an ad hominem by suggesting that the main audience is sexually hypertensive adolescents." That part of my post was autobiographical. But still, I think you're fixating on the sex even more than I was--intellectually inclined, socially outcast adolescents without a taste for rough sex are a better audience for Rand than socially accepted or intellectually incurious adolescents could ever be.