4 ms·
It's terrible that this young man committed suicide, but it there any evidence that it was Uber's fault? Is the racism claim based purely on lack of hiring div
by Chris2048 10y ago
It's terrible that this young man committed suicide, but it there any evidence that it was Uber's fault?
Is the racism claim based purely on lack of hiring diversity? If Thomas was given unforgiving or impossible tasks, why would he refuse to quit?
- kafkaesq 10y agoIs there any evidence that it was Uber's fault? There is in the article. That is, if you actually read the article.
- chicagodev 10y agoThere is actually zero evidence in the article aside from the deceased's lawyer saying the following: “We think it was stress and harassment induced by his job, between him being one of the few African Americans there, working around the clock and the culture of Uber,” That isn't evidence. That's speculation by the family's lawyer.
- jimmywanger 10y agoThere isn't in the article. The article is full of suppositions and what-ifs. There wasn't a single thing pointed out unique to Uber that doesn't occur in any other high-stress job. Also the addition of racism really muddies the waters. If you say that everything is due to racism, that term rapidly loses all meaning.
- kafkaesq 10y agoAlso the addition of racism really muddies the waters. Given the various factors at play, I would investigate further before offering such a blanket dismissal. But that's just me.
- jimmywanger 10y agoWhat other factors are there? The article has brought up none. The reasoning of the matter is this: Uber has few black technical employees, one black employee committed suicide, hence racism. Or is there something else that is missing? You realize that the same argument could be made (and has been made) for female employees? <tech companies> have few female technical employees, one female employee complains, hence <systematic sexism, "bro culture">.
- kafkaesq 10y agoUber has few black technical employees, Along with a culture of bro-ishness and clique-iness, hypercompetitiveness and backstabbing, and a sweeping disdain for ethics in general. You forgot those parts.
- jimmywanger 10y agoRelate that to racism. You forgot that part.
- flukus 10y agoThe onus of evidence is on the person making the claim.
- Chris2048 10y ago1) If you're going to say that, actually quote what you consider to be evidence, I did read the article. 2) HN guidelines specifically prohibit questioning whether someone read an article.
- kafkaesq 10y agoAs to (1) see my post above, please. 2) HN guidelines specifically prohibit questioning whether someone read an article. Noted, thanks. But general principles dictate one should also be more circumspect in addressing the circumstances of persons who have committed suicide (apparently after suffering a great deal of anguish). It seemed the person I was responding to was belittling those circumstances, in this case.
- Chris2048 10y ago> It seemed the person I was responding to was belittling those circumstances, in this case. I disagree, the article still contains no indication of fault on Ubers part - it's entirely that Thomas was finding the job stressful, which may have contributed to his suicide. Further, if by "circumspect in addressing the circumstances" you mean considering that Uber could be at fault is beside the point - I said the article gives no indication of how Uber is at fault, only the fact of the suicide and the implication of blame. I think a published article should be more circumspect of pointing the finger like this - Uber may have its day in court, but not before the accusation harms its reputation.
- kafkaesq 10y agoI said the article gives no indication of how Uber is at fault, Well, we disagree then.
- kafkaesq 10y agoAs to "evidence" (not all of it necessarily court-admissible -- but certainly enough preponderance of indication that it may have been Uber's fault, enough to warrant further investigation): But at Uber, Thomas struggled in a way he’d never experienced in over a decade in technology. He worked long hours. He told his father and his wife that he felt immense pressure and stress at work, and was scared he’d lose his job. They urged him to see a psychiatrist. He told the doctor he was having panic attacks, trouble concentrating and near-constant anxiety. All suggested that he leave his job, but he was adamant that he could not. “He was always the smartest guy in the room,” said his father, Joe Thomas. But while working at Uber, “he went down the tubes. He became someone with very little confidence in himself. The guy just fell apart.” “It’s hard to explain, but he wasn’t himself at all,” said Zecole Thomas. “He’d say things like, ‘My boss doesn’t like me.’ His personality changed totally; he was horribly concerned about his work, to the point it was almost unbelievable. He was saying he couldn’t do anything right.” And: In the case of Joseph Thomas, medical records from two East Bay psychiatrists he visited in the weeks before his suicide show that he reported job-related “high anxiety,” panic attacks, difficulty concentrating and insomnia. About a month before his suicide, Joseph Thomas disclosed his work stress in a Facebook chat to a close friend of more than a decade, Neil Mirchandani. “Man words can’t really describe. I’m not dead but I wouldn’t describe myself as ok,” Thomas wrote, according to screenshots of the chat provided by Mirchandani. “The sad thing is this place (Uber) has broken me to the point where I don’t have the strength to look for another job,” Thomas wrote.
- jimmywanger 10y ago> but certainly enough preponderance of indication What does that mean exactly? The only people who are giving the "evidence" or "indication" are the people who stand to profit the most. Once you get something that says that Uber is either racist or promotes work practices that lead to suicide, by un-unbiased external party, that's interesting. It's surprising how otherwise intelligent seeming people can get taken in by not understanding inherent conflicts of interests in cases like this.
- Chris2048 10y agoThe job causing Thomas stress isn't the same as Uber doing something wrong.