3 ms·
> Even this is not sufficient -- the fact is that this is a methodological statistical error, not a mathematical statistical error. That said, Wansink's papers
by danso 10y ago
> Even this is not sufficient -- the fact is that this is a methodological statistical error, not a mathematical statistical error.
That said, Wansink's papers had plenty of mathematical statistical errors that were evident without access to the original data, as documented in the mentioned "Statistical Heartburn" preprint: https://peerj.com/preprints/2748.pdf https://peerj.com/preprints/2748.pdf
- andrewla 10y agoVery much so -- I had only read the first part of the article when I wrote this reply, having read the whole thing now (and the linked pizza paper) I'm more than a little horrified at what can, in the most optimistic case, be described as extreme carelessness. I have a pre-existing bias against papers relating to nutrition science, and this looks worse even than I expect. I would love to see a treatment that looks at especially noteworthy research in the area that passes a rigorous methodological review, much less has been replicated with any reliability.