7 ms·
How to write a "Malcolm Gladwell Bestseller"
- dmitri1981 16y agoThe Long Tail by Chris Anderson seems to fit the criteria extremely well. He must have figured out the MGB method before you.
- asdflkj 16y agoHow to read a "Malcolm Gladwell Bestseller": start in the middle; read 20 pages or so; see sloppy reasoning and general lack of substance; don't read it or any of the author's other books again. You'd save yourself a lot of time if you did that, jgrahamc.
- fgf 16y agoI enjoyed the debate between Gladwell and Steven Pinker after Pinker wrote a negative book review. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/15/books/review/Pinker-t.html?_r=1 http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/15/books/review/Pinker-t.html... http://papercuts.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/19/malcolm-gladwell-responds-to-steven-pinker/ http://papercuts.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/11/19/malcolm-gladwe...
- barry-cotter 16y agoThat's not a debate, that's a Pinker curb-stomping Gladwell, hardly surprising when Steve Sailer is entirely capable of doing it.
- replicatorblog 16y agoThe sloppy reasoning/lack of substance are features, not bugs. He isn't a serious intellectual gladiator, he is a merchant who makes soundbites that educated, upper middle class people can use to sound intelligent and well read. As long as people view them as such it is not problem. My frustration is when people cite Gladwell's ideas as either 1) the basis for strategic decision making at a business 2) the grounds for a major public policy decisions. On a side note, I'd love to see this kind of breakdown for a lot of the shows on NPR, especially This American Life
- asdflkj 16y agoWhy are we wasting time on this then? There's nothing new or interesting about making dumb stuff that appeals to dumb people.
- travem 16y agoAs an interesting book countering the "blink" concept is a book called "Think!: Why Crucial Decisions Can't Be Made in the Blink of an Eye" - http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1416531556?ie=UTF8&tag=benmeadowcrho-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=1416531556 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1416531556?ie=UTF8&tag=...
- simplegeek 16y agoWell, this may sound obvious to many but I think #1 should be "Become a regular reader of few psychological and social academic journals". I guess this alone can give you few ideas to write essays. Now my question is that, anyone know if journals of repute(related to psychological and social) can be accessed online?
- shrikant 16y agohttp://ssrn.com/ http://ssrn.com/
- jamesbkel 16y agoThe Society for Judgement and Decision Making has been publishing an online journal for about 4-5 years now. Very respected Editor and Assoc. Editors and certainly some interesting papers in there. http://journal.sjdm.org/ http://journal.sjdm.org/ Also, I've found it useful to build a list of researchers whose work I find interesting, then trawl Google Scholar for them; this usually turns up some free sources that would be otherwise hard to find in the noise.
- napierzaza 16y agoThis article is very strange. It's pretty cynical about Gladwell but his details on him aren't all negative are they? Gladwell sure is good at telling stories and proving points! It has to be a formula. A formula of what pretty much equals good writing and research.
- roundsquare 16y agoEntertaining writing, maybe, but certainly not good/education writing. And certainly not good research. Side note: He may have solid research, but it doesn't come out in the writing.
- kenjackson 16y agoAnd to be frank, most research isn't "good research" either. With that said, much of what he's doing is constructing a framework and then building into it. This is actually similar to what is done in a lot of social science research. And Gladwell, often does it much better, even from a purely academic perspective. The main issue is that millions of people read and scrutinize Gladwell. No one reads "A Critique of 12th Century Eastern European Poetry and the Relationship to Subsurface Climate Volatility".
- kurtosis 16y agoPerhaps the sad fact is that being entertaining and being accurate are conflicting goals. Who wants to listen to a complex explanation for why the "fifteen minutes of videotaped conversation" method (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Gottman http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Gottman )for predicting the likelihood of divorce is flawed due to overfitting issues (see http://www.stat.columbia.edu/~cook/movabletype/archives/2010/03/shooting_down_b.html http://www.stat.columbia.edu/~cook/movabletype/archives/2010... for details) Gladwell doesn't let complex facts get in the way of a good story.
- statictype 16y agoIt's not meant to be research. If it were, wouldn't it be published in an academic journal?
- 16y ago
- erikstarck 16y agoHe missed "get a funky haircut".
- lhorie 16y agoFWIW, one could argue that many of these elements are also present in a book like Godel Escher Bach. - Your book is actually going to be a collection of essays drawn together by a loose thread. - "strange loops" - Each of your essays is going to revolve around a single idea - pretty much every Achilles and Tortoise chapter - Illustrate the idea with stories about real people - Godel, Escher, Bach and so on... I don't know about the rest of you, but I read Gladwell and Hofstadter because they are entertaining in an brain-stimulating way. When I want raw non-embezzled science, I read scientific papers. In both cases, I'll come to my own conclusions. I don't get all this passive-agressive "holier-than-thou" attitude towards Gladwell being famous I've been seeing lately. Who cares if he's famous?
- pwhelan 16y ago'I don't get all this passive-agressive "holier-than-thou" attitude towards Gladwell being famous I've been seeing lately. Who cares if he's famous?' It reminds me of what PG said about this in his "why to not not start a startup" -- he is successful for what he does and they don't think he should be because he writes about things he doesn't do professionally or something.
- efsavage 16y agoGladwell is a fantastic storyteller. Unfortunately, this isn't obvious to many people, who seem to think he's a scientist or a journalist, despite no claims on his part for these qualifications or assertions that his work stands up to the rigors of those disciplines. They have decided that he is one or both of these things, and since he isn't, he does not fare well when assessed along those lines. He writes very well, his books are interesting, his anecdotes are carefully selected and edited. His conclusions are meant to spark conversation, not end them. Lighten up.
- lee 16y agoAgreed! Gladwell's work is entertaining and mildly thought provoking. Sure, his work can be broken down into a pattern or formula but his execution is fantastic. Just like creating anything else in life: Starting up a software business = think of a solution, talk to customers, write some code, repeat until you've built something of value. Writing any essay = brainstorm some ideas, write them down, edit and proof-read, repeat until you've got a polished paper. I guess success draws a lot of criticism.
- pavs 16y agoI haven't read any of his books, though I got many recommendations from friends. Which one should I start with? (don't care much about relevance to startup/business, as long as its a good book)
- tokenadult 16y agoOutliers is a good read that correctly represents a lot of new research about its subject. After edit: I say this because I had read many of the primary and secondary sources cited in Gladwell's notes before his book came out. I still learned new facts from his book.
- AlisdairO 16y agoI enjoyed Outliers. I liked the fact that, while the premise of the book is that the ultra-successful tend to have quite a lot of luck on their side, he never fails to mention that it also takes hard work/talent.
- LucaDuval 16y agoIt probably also helps to be a talented public speaker and he is reputed to be a very good one. http://blogs.ft.com/rachmanblog/2010/02/the-secrets-of-malcolm-gladwell/ http://blogs.ft.com/rachmanblog/2010/02/the-secrets-of-malco... Generally speaking lot of bestsellers, fiction or non fiction, can be synthesized as: - give to the reader pre-digested, easy, spoonfuls of information. - give to the reader something to quote so that he can appear smart to his friends. - try to be appealling enough to be interviewed on TV.
- kmfrk 16y agoHe also did great at The Moth with a personal story. http://www.themoth.org/podcast http://www.themoth.org/podcast He's also done one or several Ted talks. I recommend the one on spaghetti sauce.
- raganwald 16y agoGetting away from criticizing or praising Mr. Gladwell, many, many authors have noticed that an effective way to write multiple best-sellers is to find a formula that works and stick to it. Michael Crighton is said to have read many best sellers and made notes about their structure so that he could develop his own formula for writing a best-selling novel.
- c00p3r 16y agobooks actually contain very few ideas. But these few ideas are chosen to be interesting to a general reader, to be understandable by a layman - take almost any religious books - it is the same collection of short stories for a layman, which illustrate one simple idea at a time, so the formula was a thousands years old. =) Some of them were poetry in original language. btw, famous books by Dale Carnegie are brilliant adoption of that style. bbtw, in many cases of such writers (compilators) the first book is the best one. The Tipping Point (and, of course, How To Find Friends) is really enjoying one.
- aresant 16y agoAuthor misses Gladwell's largest advantage: he became a bestseller because he had laid the groundwork with years of writing magazine articles - built up an audience and alliances with huge, influential publications like the new yorker, NYT, etc.
- tjmaxal 16y agoIf you are the type of reader that accepts everything you read as fact, then pointing out a formula isn't going to change that now is it? Most popular TV shows are written on a 3 act formula yet you can still find them engaging, germane, and thought provoking. In short formulas do not equal thoughtlessness.
- stickhandle 16y agoThe way to "read" Gladwell is to get the talking-book and have him read it to you as you commute to work/home. He's a great storyteller - in both word and voice. And he delivers his own material extraordinarily well. I've listened to all 3 of the books mentioned and am currently enjoying his collection of NYer essays "What the Dog Saw". His essay on Ron Popeil was terrific. Word of warning though ... you might find yourself sad to arrive at your destination and just sit in the car an extra few mins to finish a section!
- kadavy 16y agoSo basically, writing a "Malcolm Gladwell Bestseller" requires a shitload of work.