4 ms·
> a data set is not completely worthless if it showed a null result. Why is a null result worthless? I don't understand. It goes against my common sense that p
by StavrosK 10y ago
> a data set is not completely worthless if it showed a null result.
Why is a null result worthless? I don't understand. It goes against my common sense that paying more for food doesn't make you eat more. The fact that this is not the case is valuable knowledge to me. I understand that it's not as glamorous as "paying more makes you eat less!", but it's still valuable knowledge that should be published.
- draw_down 10y agoI think you're saying the same thing as GP
- ad-hominem 10y ago> a data set is not completely worthless if it showed a null result. A null result is not worthless. A data set is not worthless if it showed a null result. Nobody is claiming a null result is worthless. Even the original article gives a good reason for publishing a null result.
- KingMob 10y agoNull results are "worthless" only in the sense that they're harder, if not impossible, to publish, and do less for your career. As a former neuroscientist, I had a unicorn data set of intracranial EEG data, and we'd spent so much time collecting it, that we were determined to find something. I left grad school before we found anything of interest. I believe my former prof eventually published something on it, but I analyzed the shit out of it, even knowing I was fishing, because so much time would have been lost to not use it. Fishing like this was one of the reasons I left. The pursuit of knowledge and the pursuit of your career don't align often enough. To me, what's unusual is not that Wansink pushed to keep analyzing the data, but that he was called out for it. Everyone seemed to be doing it when I was in academia.
- noobhacker 10y agoI feel the same way about current practice research, but find that industry standards are even more abysmal in terms of fishing. What field are you in now that you find an acceptable level of rigor?
- KingMob 10y agoHah, well, I returned to software dev, so I'm not too worried about research rigor these days.