3 ms·
Because you asked: I did not initially downvote your comment. However, as the asker of the question, I understood the phrase "Apple's term for RTM" was just a c
by gojomo 16y ago
Because you asked: I did not initially downvote your comment. However, as the asker of the question, I understood the phrase "Apple's term for RTM" was just a compact way of saying, "the term used by Apple for the concept some others call RTM". I did not detect any implication in that wording that "Golden Master" was uniquely or primarily or even originally Apple's term.
But you read those more specific implications into the statement. Out of two ways to read the answer, you chose the less-charitable interpretation: that the writer was making a stronger claim, and misleading people. In that sense, I can understand downvotes as trying to send the message: read charitably, assume the best-possible-interpretation of comments, and save your corrections/clarifications for things that are wrong under all interpretations, not just one strict interpretation. Otherwise we get crazy meta-tangents like this.
Finally, though, the 'dispute' (such as there is one) motivated me to actually read the Wikipedia article and Google ["golden master"] on both the web and old Usenet postings. It turns out the phrase is overwhelmingly associated with Apple, and perhaps Apple was the first to use exactly that term for a software release, in the late 80s. So the implication that it is an Apple-originated term may be appropriate, despite you having heard the term in other software contexts.