5 ms·
Finland tried this same thing with the same "dynamic effects will offset lost tax revenue!" rhetoric a few years ago, and it didn't work out anything like expec
by pavlov 10y ago
Finland tried this same thing with the same "dynamic effects will offset lost tax revenue!" rhetoric a few years ago, and it didn't work out anything like expected.
At the start of 2014, Finland lowered its corporate tax rate to 20% (from a previous 24.5%). The lost tax revenue amounted to $800M EUR, but the government claimed that half of that would be recouped thanks to positive dynamic effects the tax cut would create in the national economy.
Two years later, they were forced to admit [1] that none of those dynamic effects materialized.
Cutting corporate tax may still be a good thing, but it's most likely nothing close to revenue-neutral anywhere in the developed world. So this plan would expand the US budget deficit (which Republicans seem to hate only when they're not the ones expanding it with tax cuts).
[1] http://yle.fi/uutiset/3-7773569 http://yle.fi/uutiset/3-7773569 (in Finnish)
- mjfl 10y agoTo play devil's advocate, Finland was giving sort of a vague argument for their tax cuts: "dynamic effects", while in America there are very concrete potential effects of the policy. You can point directly to Apple and say, "If we cut tax rates to 15%, Apple will bring back $X to the USA", "Exxon Mobile will bring back $X to USA", and so on. You can even... talk to them and ask them what it would take to repatriate the offshore funds, and I would hope Trump would do that. So yeah, I think it's one thing to cut taxes and hope "economic growth" happens automatically, but a completely different thing if you have a quantifiable number of offshore dollars, deals can be made, etc.
- muninn_ 10y agoEventually that money will be either returned to share holders, or will be invested in the business. You also have to consider that the government in Finland is probably way less shitty than the US government.
- vannevar 10y agoThis is a race to the bottom. There is no public policy reason that corporations, particularly public corporations, should be allowed to amass such enormous piles of cash.
- tmaly 10y agoI think the small businesses, the mom and pop shops that cannot afford a fleet of accountants, will benefit the most from a lower tax.
- dplgk 10y agoHow does lower or higher tax changes the amount of accountants you need?
- dmix 10y agoComplex tax code = lots of loops that can be found via a team of accountants Therefore the big firms that everyone villianizes for paying little taxes are already paying low taxes. This would lower the taxes for those who can't afford the team of accountants. Ideally they should also dramatically simplify the tax code to eliminate all of the loopholes so everyone pays the expected rates and there are no reinforcing cyclical benefits for market incumbents crippling innovation and continually enriching a small subset of the population.